4 ms·
I dislike fiddles to laws, about as much as I dislike legal reductionism, although I am attracted to simpler laws but really, weaponising lawsuit against peer r
by ggm 3y ago
I dislike fiddles to laws, about as much as I dislike legal reductionism, although I am attracted to simpler laws but really, weaponising lawsuit against peer review science feels like something we want legislative guardrails on.
If this suit has standing, then pretty much any corporate can take down academic research and journals in a field which negatively impacts their domain of profit.
Seriously: basic research on lung cancer, AGW, heavy metal pollution, lead in petrol, aspartame, where does it end, if "you broke my product profit chain" is viable?
Not that bad science wouldn't be very destructive weaponised the other way: Helen Caldecott's relentless (in my view) a-scientific anti nuke stuff comes to mind. "No safe limit" has been widely abused.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]