3 ms·
It's relatively easy to reject "dirty money" if it's extra money on top of your normal, sustainable income. It's much harder to reject when you literally don't
by nine_k 3y ago
It's relatively easy to reject "dirty money" if it's extra money on top of your normal, sustainable income. It's much harder to reject when you literally don't know how are you going to feed yourself, or your children, next week. This is what the poorest face.
- glimshe 3y agoAgreed. Even in fairly normal jobs like hotel room cleaning, workers have to endure indignities that a person with a reasonably high, stable income would never want to endure, such as handling bed sheets with bodily fluids, entering rooms with naked people etc. People who endure this humiliation usually have few other options. In the case of room cleaning, the downsides are largely intrinsic to the job and not necessarily immoral in my point of view - even if we should put mechanisms in place to try to get these people better pay. However, in the case of the TikTok videos, it's purely about exploiting the desperation of others, so I can't put it in the same level as normal unpleasant jobs.
- cafard 3y agoMechanisms in place: unions?
- autoexec 3y agoI don't really consider this "dirty money". Not as long as nobody is being hurt by it. I'm not worried about people willing to humiliate themselves for money (assuming that they're even bothered by what others would find humiliating). It's the people willing to hurt others for money that bother me most. The ones knowingly selling poisoned or unsafe products because they'll save a fraction of a cent per unit sold. That's "dirty money" to me. It's usually being done by people who already have obscene amounts of wealth too, but even in cases where someone is struggling to feed themselves or their children it doesn't give them the right to hurt others. That's a choice. People who scam and exploit others for profit are just evil.
- nine_k 3y ago"Dirty" here is subjective: something I personally find off-putting, disgusting, and even morally wrong, but have to do anyway to avoid starving my children, or similar.
- analognoise 3y agoWe have so much food we waste 50% of it and we have two individuals with effectively private space companies. Maybe it shouldn't be ok, and we should level the field a bit instead?
- nine_k 3y agoThe problem is not in "us" having too much. Also at least one of the private space companies definitely makes a positive difference in the world. It's "them" not being able to have enough. Mostly it's not even a supply-side problem: huge amounts of humanitarian aid go to e.g. certain parts of Africa. It's the local power structures that want to stay on top and subdue or crush any competition, and / or advance some religious cause. They don't care about their population starving. They directly forbid and resist e.g. handing out too much food, etc, because it undermines positions of their power, their chokehold on resources. This can't be realistically solved by sending even more aid (it will convert into even more corruption, yachts, and houses in Toronto and London). It can't even be solved with bombs, bullets, and removal of the current crop of corrupt petty dictators: a new crop would appear instantly. This likely can be healed by relatively slow education, information, economic nudges, and providing examples of well-functioning societies.
- newaccount74 3y agoAnother problem with sending surplus food to developing countries is that it just destroys the little local economy they have. I think education is one thing, but some form of financial or economic aid is probably also needed, but how to do it in a way that sustainably improves the economy is hard.