3 ms·
I get songs stuck in my head, but I don't imagine other peoples voices, nor do I "hear" sounds of instruments or similar - if I imagine music I imagine myself h
by vidarh 3y ago
I get songs stuck in my head, but I don't imagine other peoples voices, nor do I "hear" sounds of instruments or similar - if I imagine music I imagine myself humming it.
But these things appear to not be directly linked - far more people have no voice in their head than have issues seeing things (about 2% or so see nothing). Similarly I was shocked to realise that a lot of people have no internal monologue or conversation - I have a constant monologue going in my head my ever waking moment other than when I suppress it with meditation.
Here's an interesting article that addresses some of these additional aspects [1], and which interestingly fall in the same trap of assuming their experience is universal when they write:
> The idea of an internal dialogue – rather than a monologue – will be familiar to anyone who’s ever rehearsed an important conversation, or rehashed an argument, in their mind.
But that is not true for me. I rehearse pretty much every conversation I know will happen, but the other side is always silent. I know what I think they'd answer and I practice my side, but there's no voice - mine or others - voicing the rest.
For others there is, and for some whole discussions with multiple different voices can happen (sometimes that can indicate a mental health problem, but usually that boils down to whether they're intrusive or beyond your control)
[1] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190819-what-your-inner-voice-says-about-you https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190819-what-your-inner-...