3 ms·
Speaking from experience, the issue is that as a manager most of the power comes from being able to dictate how the relationship works (at least in the short te
by roenxi 3y ago
Speaking from experience, the issue is that as a manager most of the power comes from being able to dictate how the relationship works (at least in the short term, long term employees can quit).
> I was desperately trying to prove that I didn’t feel superior, wrapping feedback in all sorts of caveats...
This is how your instincts get you as a manager. The strong desire to dictate how the relationship will flow is the little monkey inside coming out to show dominance. In extreme cases, managers show off by neglecting their leadership duties under the guise of being friendly but actually just lazing around in a conspicuous consumption style display. Humans are very tuned to status, his reports were not fooled for a moment. Unless they were hopelessly naive, they knew that this man could get them fired.
A much fairer and more effective approach is to focus on the realities of the situation as best as is possible. Don't pretend to be equal, you have more power. Don't pretend to be better, you're just another opinion as far as the realities of the situation are concerned. Only force someone to do something if there is a reason or a necessity to it, ideally just find the overlap between what the reports think is high value work and what you agree with them on. Be scrupulously fair and reasonable, fight instinct and bias.
There is no such thing as autonomy when a manager's opinions will influence how a report's career progresses. To pretend otherwise is negligent, unprofessional management. Managers have power, they should exercise their influence to the betterment of their team. People in notional positions of leadership have a responsibility to make sure people are going somewhere that is better than where they are. Good managers lead. Although sometimes they lead by identifying a technical expert and leaving them alone to do something.
- kardianos 3y agoThe same lessons can be applied to parenting. You should care about your children's well being deeply, but you are not their friend. You have authority over them. You may get to be their friend as they grow up and become independent, but a parent over their children has power that must be put into play for your child's benefit. This is also why Marxism is always a lie. There will be people who have power over others. Saying otherwise is just an authoritarian lie. Progressives: beware of the reality of power and responsibility; it is better to be aware of your power and bear it, then to lie about it and ignore it as if you don't have influence over others. We are not all equal in our authority, but we should all be given the same procedural processes to advance or in discipline.