4 ms·
Social media riot shutdowns possible under EU content law, top official says
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>Social media platforms like TikTok and Snapchat will face possible shutdowns when they don't crack down on problematic content Ok, and who defines what exactly is "problematic content"? Let me guess, it's gonna be whatever the government wants silenced. >"When there is hateful content, content that calls – for example – for revolt, that also calls for killing and burning of cars, they will be required to delete [the content] immediately," Aha, but if I invite 100k people to a meeting in the city center next to the parliament building for a peaceful protest, that will be fine and not get removed, right? Right?
- moring 3y agoAn optimistic view would be that courts decide what is right and wrong. They are supposed to be independent of both the government and the parliament, and if you fear a dystopian future where they aren't, shutting down TikTok isn't going to be our biggest problem.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoI don't get your comment. The police can come break up mass gatherings without consulting with the courts first.
- amarant 3y agoLaws vary a bit from country to country in Europe, but here in Sweden at least the cops have to protect the safety of the people in the mass gatherings, safeguarding their right to protest/demonstrate/whatever. This system has really been put to the test lately when some right wing extremists wanted to burn the Quran outside of mosques. The police really didn't want to allow that, but were in the end forced to protect the demonstrations, since even boneheaded Nazis have freedom of speech here, no matter how dumb and inflammatory their speech is. This has really caused some diplomatic problems for the government, who are trying to convince Turkey (a predominantly Muslim country) to allow us to join NATO. Burning the Quran and angering every Muslim in the world has not helped that cause. Now it seems burning stuff is becoming a trend, the other day someone made the news for burning a printout of their municipalities traffic guidelines, which was kinda funny. Given how much the government and the police wanted to stop these things, and yet still ended up helping them happen(in accordance to Swedish constitution) makes me not worry overmuch that Europe will become Soviet. Unless Russia conquers us all, then we'll be the Soviet Union for sure.
- fufirjr 3y agoI think it's mistaken to compare the two rather than seeing one as an extension of the other. Police already have the tools and authority to police an active riot into submission. The decision to go easy on riots is a political one motivated by a desire not to jeopardize their current powers. This doesn't mean expanding their powers is necessary or desirable even if the courts are involved however.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gmerc 3y agoYou’d be surprised that if you show pornography or gore porn in public, the police can and will take you down in the US too without a court order. So what defines problematic content? The law.
- justinclift 3y ago"Uneven application of the law" is generally what people seem to have issues with.
- gmerc 3y agoThat’s exactly what is being addressed. The uneven application in virtual space vs meat space.
- justinclift 3y agoWell, it doesn't seem to be applied evenly in meat space yet either. ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gettodachoppa 3y agoI don't understand how you can question this, are you trying to stop our government from being able to fight right-wing Russian misinformation trolls? With attitudes like that, Ukraine will lose. Upvotes to the left, folks.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoAh yes, the invisible boogieman, Russian online trolls, the reason we should all give up our rights, "for your safety". "but think of the children".
- hunglee2 3y agoMost patriots would support this move. Remember that foreign agents of hostile powers can infiltrate social media platforms and agitate the public into revolt. In fact, this was official US / big tech policy during the Arab Spring, leading the Syrian Civil War amongst other catastrophes. We would do best to prevent the same techniques applied by others, to us
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago>Most patriots would support this move. Ah, the modern 'No true Scotsman (2001 RIP)'.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago[flagged]
- waihtis 3y agoGreat living in the EU: -Economy become stagnant (EU economy was 10% larger than the US economy in 2005; in 2022, US economy was 40% larger than the EU's) -Ever increasing power centralization into Brussels with all kinds of fun instruments like joint debt -Censorship laws coming up Nothing can convince me the end result won't be something akin to the Soviet Union. All the right mechanisms are creeping into place
- gls2ro 3y agoYeah lets break down EU and then start a limiteless number of wars as Europe was before EU. Cause the alternative is centralization under a parliament in Brusells. Is that something that you really equal to Soviet Union?
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoI think you're exaggerating with the Soviet Union comparison. But yeah, the economy and jobs market is pretty stagnant. What's not stagnant is the housing market. We're gonna be like Canada soon.
- OscarCunningham 3y ago> EU economy was 10% larger than the US economy in 2005; in 2022, US economy was 40% larger than the EU's How much of that is due to the UK leaving?
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoseems unlikely to be a significant amount - given https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/germany/uk https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/germany/uk on edit: actually thinking about it, since Germany is about 21% of economy and England is slightly under Germany I guess England could be responsible for a significant amount of that loss - assuming significance is more than 15% of the loss.
- kmlx 3y agoyes, it was a big amount, and it affected all the stats.
- perihelions 3y ago- "Some critics likened this to measures seen in authoritarian states like China and Iran." To distinguish the actions you would need a magnifying glass and a thesaurus. (Which any number of pundits are about to dust off from their bookshelves. Because: moral valence flows from the actor to the action. Obviously the authoritarian regimes oppress their people; obviously the free democracies protect their peoples' freedom and security. It takes conscious effort to reverse the causal order—to judge the actor by their actions, not re-interpret the actions on the fly to the fit the actor).
- cuuupid 3y agoEquating everything to China or middle eastern countries is the 2023 equivalent of equating everything to Hitler. This is bad but not yet _that_ bad. I have to say though, EU legislature in recent years is on a very slippery slope.
- akira2501 3y agoI don't think viewing the nation with the "Great Firewall" as a polemic in this debate is anywhere near such equivocations.
- perihelions 3y agoThat's kind of the point I was going for in my (post-edit) comment. EU countries are broadly very free countries, totally and qualitatively unlike the authoritarian exemplars. The threat of shutting down social media to quench anti-government protests, specifically, is very, very like parallel examples from repressive dictatorships. It's a thought-terminating cliche to erase this second observation by overwriting it with the first.
- bhawks 3y agoCan't trust the people to be able to speak to each other. People will get hurt if they have to think for themselves. If the people are revolting it is definitely illegitimate on their part, our dear leaders are infallible in their efforts to do what's best for them. How far our 'leaders' have fallen.
- tap-snap-or-nap 3y agoIt is clear that misleaders are currently in power.
- sebazzz 3y agoOr maybe it is just "A person is smart, people are stupid", "Broken window theory", etc.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/dLVPW https://archive.is/dLVPW
- throwawayfeu 3y agoThis is unacceptable. Taking basic rights away from people
- constantcrying 3y agoSo the solution to massive social unrest is to get people to stop talking about it? Just pretend it is not happening and everything is going to be fine.
- rightbyte 3y agoGoing after the symptoms rather than the causes. Our leaders are so narcissistic and think so high of themself and low of us that they can't fathom that any discontent from their subjects are real and not some manufactured discontent from the whatever country they happen to war monger against. That said social media is toxic and I am quite sure Facebook and Twitter have manipulated the feeds to incite discontent in countries that is on the Washington shit list. When they shut down social media it was seen as an attack on democracy ...
- raincom 3y agoHahaha, when third world countries suppress social media, NGOs, USAID, the West bemoans the fact that liberal values of the hour (freedom, suppression of minorities, independent media, etc) are suppressed. When it comes to the West, blame it on "disinformation campaign by Russia/China, election interference, public interest being suppressed, etc". At least in the third world, ordinary people know that freedom depends on the enforcers of the state machinery, and they don't cite constitution or statues or liberal values. Enter the West: it is a different game.