4 ms·
On the other hand, making a movie is terrifyingly expensive. Substantially reducing the cost will mean more movies get made, which means more demand for front l
by WalterBright 3y ago
On the other hand, making a movie is terrifyingly expensive. Substantially reducing the cost will mean more movies get made, which means more demand for front line actors.
After all, what happened when the printing press replaced the monks copying books by hand, letter by letter, in ink?
- midoridensha 3y agoA lot of the cost is top-billed actors' salaries. They could reduce that greatly by simply not using A-list actors (unless they agree to a huge paycut), but they don't want to do that because A-list actors bring more viewers. Meanwhile modern movies usually have lousy scripts. This problem is one that the movie studios have created all by themselves.
- WalterBright 3y agoI'm looking forward to the day when anyone can hand a book to an AI and tell it to generate a movie from it. At least there'll be no more complaints about "not following the book!"
- midoridensha 3y agoPerhaps, but you'll probably wind up with a shitty movie. Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and a story that works well in a book usually, IMO, just won't translate well to a 2-4 hour movie without making major changes to the story and plot. However, perhaps instead of trying to make movies from books, they should make miniseries (3-10 hour-long episodes).
- jredwards 3y agoBecause if there's anything AI currently sucks at, it's giving a reasonable summary of a larger context. I think Book --> Movie Script is probably going to arrive before generated actors.
- midoridensha 3y agoYou're right: the current quality of film/TV scripts is terrible, so this is definitely one place where LLMs could do far, far better than most humans in the profession.
- WalterBright 3y agoLord of the Rings was considered unfilmable for decades. Computers made it possible.
- midoridensha 3y agoI'm not referring to the technical aspects of filming, I'm referring to the huge differences between them as a storytelling medium. A movie only has 1.5-3 hours of screen time available to tell the complete story (unless you do something like the recent "Dune" movies, or make a trilogy like LotR), but in addition to that, a lot of things that work for books don't work the same way for movies: pacing, etc.
- richardw 3y agoNah, just generate the A listers, or make better actors that are better looking and have better voices. Generate the directors, generate the whole movie. Put me in the movie, make me better looking. Toss the studios.
- h0l0cube 3y agoThere’s hardly a scarcity of movies at the moment
- WalterBright 3y agoCompared to books, it's orders of magnitude.
- h0l0cube 3y agoAll for indie producers to be able to self-publish their own CG masterpieces (that's already a thing that happens on YouTube), but they'll probably not use the puppeted likenesses of real people that have been grifted from them by egregious contracts from Hollywood Studios (as per TFA)
- antisthenes 3y agoBooks are overrated. I've read a fair bit of fantasy fiction (think Lord of the Rings derivatives), and after roughly 25-30 books, it just becomes a slog to read through, there are very few original ideas.
- cloverich 3y agoI think there _is_ a scarcity of quality movies that don't follow predictable / mainstream cliches. Because its too risky to sink a lot of money into something niche. AI will change that. The number one thing it is going to do is reduce the time, effort, and money involved in creating quality films. The result will be more trash for sure. But also more high quality stuff, and a LOT more stuff tailored to narrower interests. And its probably going to be very cheap, and perhaps free for much of it. We'll still see mainstream franchises though, because IMHO it serves as a form of social glue, i.e. gives people common things to talk about and experiences to share.
- scentoni 3y agoThe studio executives are trying to extinguish quality movies because they only want predictable mainstream cliches that can churned out inexpensively in enormous volume from AI on a regular schedule.
- dclowd9901 3y agoYellow journalism happened
- coolandsmartrr 3y agoMore movie means more choice in the market to the point of confusion among consumers. Further increasing film output may be detrimental to the market; moviegoers may get alienated by unfamiliar choices, and films may find it more difficult to recoup costs. The reasons franchises, especially superheroes, have been thriving in the last two decades is because of the excessive choice of movies. The general public struggles to pick which one to watch, so they pick franchises with expected plots. This market trend is partly why Disney's Bob Iger bet on franchises, acquiring Marvel and Lucasfilms. The paradox of choice is best illustrated in Sheena Iyengar's "The Art of Choosing." An experiment showed that when supermarket shoppers were presented with more choices for a category (e.g. jam), they stuck to the choices they were already familiar with.
- WalterBright 3y agoDoes the great mass of books available confuse people?
- mitchdoogle 3y agoYes , they are so paralyzed by choice they choose not to read any at all.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y ago> The reasons franchises, especially superheroes, have been thriving in the last two decades is because of the excessive choice of movies. The general public struggles to pick which one to watch, so they pick franchises with expected plots. This market trend is partly why Disney's Bob Iger bet on franchises, acquiring Marvel and Lucasfilms. I don’t think this is true. Consolidation of film properties was largely caused by the death of the tape/dvd market, which represented a significant revenue stream for movies, so the studios focused on properties that would have huge box office numbers. Matt Damon talked about this in an interview recently, saying that so many of his movies, like Good Will Hunting, would not be made today because they tended to have long tail VHS sales.
- verve_rat 3y agoIt doesn't have to be fantastically expensive to make a movie. The death of the mid budget feature is entirely of the studios' own making.
- bleuchase 3y agoMartin Luther also threatened the Catholic Church by translating the Bible from Latin into German. That was the first time people other than priests had wide access to the text directly.
- slantaclaus 3y agoHmmmmmm