4 ms·
>Its tar and feather territory if you ask me. Refusing to accept a deal is akin to acts of violence? I feel like the pro-union rhetoric is getting hyperbolic,
by gruez 3y ago
>Its tar and feather territory if you ask me.
Refusing to accept a deal is akin to acts of violence? I feel like the pro-union rhetoric is getting hyperbolic, and is detrimental to the quality of the discussion. If simply refusing to accept a deal is "tar and feather territory", then what do you call it when studios are literally covering union members in tar and feather? "tar feather (fr!) territory"? Rather than discussing actually relevant topics like which side's offer is objectively more fair, half the comments here are about trying to describe the studio's actions in increasingly hyperbolic terms.
- Woberto 3y agoI think you're vastly oversimplifying their stance as merely "refusing to accept a deal". If studios are waiting for writers to "start losing their apartments and losing their houses,"[1] that is a major negative impact to people's lives. [1] various sources, e.g. https://www.ign.com/articles/hollywood-studios-want-writers-to-go-broke-before-resuming-talks https://www.ign.com/articles/hollywood-studios-want-writers-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gruez 3y ago>that is a major negative impact to people's lives. I fully acknowledge the hardship that the union members are going through, and that the impact is likely disproportionate. However, that's a negative impact brought on by themselves by choosing to engage in said strikes. The union might still be in the "right" in terms of what they're demanding, but they're still the proximate cause of their own hardship.
- schlauerfox 3y agoThis is a very cruel take, lacking such empathy that you blame the least powerful people in an industry for demanding a living allocation of the vast wealth the industry creates from those in power that decide the allocations? Walk away from your career and surrender if your partners decide to take all the income from you? What an odd way to live your life. What an impossible way to live a life.
- gruez 3y ago>This is a very cruel take, lacking such empathy that you blame the least powerful people in an industry ... See my previous comment: "The union might still be in the "right" in terms of what they're demanding, " My only point was that the union and its members was presented with two choices: accepting a "bad" offer, or striking in hopes of getting a better offer. If they chose the latter and lost out, it was entirely their decision that led to their predicament.
- Arrath 3y ago> Refusing to accept a deal is akin to acts of violence? Its not 'refusing to accept a deal', its this: "“The endgame is to allow things to drag on until union members start losing their apartments and losing their houses,” a studio executive told Deadline." [0] I don't think I can get more hyperbolic than "our stance is we won't talk to them until they're freezing in the streets". [0] https://deadline.com/2023/07/writers-strike-hollywood-studios-deal-fight-wga-actors-1235434335/ https://deadline.com/2023/07/writers-strike-hollywood-studio...
- gruez 3y agoThe part that you're not mentioning is that the union members are choosing not to sign the deal, and therefore are freezing in the streets. This sucks for union members, but I don't see how else such negotiations are supposed to work. If there's no threat of either side not accepting a deal, then what leverage does either side have? And if the union doesn't want to accept a deal from the studios, and consequently doesn't want to work, why should the studios continue paying them?
- danaris 3y agoIt takes two to tango. The union members are choosing not to accept a deal that will leave them nearly destitute. The studio execs are choosing not to accept a deal that will...leave them still massively wealthy, just slightly less so.