A lot of the studies involved do replicate, just with reduced effects. But the presumption here is that the same experiment is even being run a second time, an

A lot of the studies involved do replicate, just with reduced effects. But the presumption here is that the same experiment is even being run a second time, and my point is that many studies who have the stated goal of replication do so in ways that I find hard to justify. So even when a study claims to "fail to replicate", I don't think we should just take that on face value.