Totally agree with your take here, although I would like to offer my perspective/speculation as someone who actually takes oral birth control daily: It may be

Totally agree with your take here, although I would like to offer my perspective/speculation as someone who actually takes oral birth control daily: It may be notable that the pill that got approved is a progestin-only pill that's been on the market for fifty years (so long enough to demonstrate safety/effectiveness) and, crucially, does not contain any estrogen. Because there are risks associated with estrogen-based birth control, to the point where I understand why the FDA might still recommend getting screened by a doctor first—most notably, there's an elevated risk of DVT if you're a smoker. Granted, given the current, uh, situation in the US, I do think people should be able to make informed decisions about that risk for themselves without needing a doctor's approval. But a progestin-only pill mitigates a lot of that risk anyway while still being a reasonably effective contraceptive.