5 ms·
The politician's use of "shared" to describe this is misleading in a way that HN headline-only readers are going to jump all over. What these sites were doing w
by jeffbee 3y ago
The politician's use of "shared" to describe this is misleading in a way that HN headline-only readers are going to jump all over. What these sites were doing was abusing Google Analytics to store private user data in custom parameters. That is, in one example, if a user of a tax prep site said that they had 1 dependent, the site would set a parameter like "cd17:1" in their Analytics request. I don't really see how that amounts to Google's problem.
If a company uses or abuses software platforms to improperly store private user data, that is their error and not the fault of the platform. I assume you would not blame Google if Intuit put everyone's AGI in a Google Sheet.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoWhy doesn't Google encrypt/decrypt the data on the client so that Google can't be accused of having access to that data?
- barrkel 3y agoI expect it's because the firms wanted to use these values in Google Analytics to do analysis of their own customers. https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/10075209?hl=en https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/10075209?hl=en
- taftster 3y agoRight. Someone at H&R Block wanted to know "what pages or functions do people with 1 dependent use the most". This query seems innocent enough. It's maybe logical and an easy thing to ask for without realizing the implications. I would bet this type of thing happens with LOTS of sites that collect any sort of personal data. Obviously for us here, blocking analytic platforms through an adblock tool is a smart thing to do, exactly for this reason. But obviously that doesn't scale to the masses.
- suslik 3y agoIsn't having access to the data the whole point of this?
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoBecause the whole point of Google Analytics is because Google wants the data. Obviously the platform here is just as much at fault as the customer using it inappropriately.
- singlow 3y agoThere is no way that google has interest in the effort it would take to try to interpret the custom data that websites insert into custom analytics dimensions in a meaningful way. Their algorithms may track trends for them, but they are not aware of what they actually mean in a semantic way. I doubt that it us useful for them to learn anything from that data that is scoped outside the single account.
- jeffbee 3y agoPeople are so confused about this. They underestimate the cost and effort that would be needed to just grovel around in GA logs and infer things, nevermind the fact that Google promises not to do it. Then the same commenters overestimate the expected value of successfully doing it, handwaving about how valuable it would be when in reality there is not a market for such data. Finally, they underestimate the risk it would pose to the adsense business, which prints more money than Jerome Powell, and the risk averse culture of Google who would not put that business in jeopardy for anything that pays less than a billion dollars per hour.
- ndlan 3y agoBecause it would be impossible for Google to do any kind of serious server side analysis of the data, which is why these companies use analytics, if Google don't have the data unencrypted.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI worked on apps where the data collected was completely empty of user-identifying information. Management seemed content with merely logging clicks from within the UI, seeing how (and how many) people used the app. Sadly I think there is a trend in our industry to gather everything, decide what you actually want/need later. I think Google (and related) are to blame for enabling this kind of "data hoovering". Giving the customer what they want at the expense of us the users is getting kinda evil.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe terms of service of Google Analytics specifically prohibit storing PII in it. "You will not and will not assist or permit any third party to pass information, hashed or otherwise, to Google that Google could use or recognize as personally identifiable information"
- nkozyra 3y agoI think you can say it's "anonymous" data in that it doesn't have name/phone/email but still be relatively fingerprint-able given additional analytics data.
- judge2020 3y agoSounds like your info is still tracking. And that level of insight only works for small companies - at a certain point you want to combine analytics from your UI with things like “is this a high value customer” or “did this customer stop using the app after experiencing this frustrating UX”
- zo1 3y agoI'm still not convinced how this is "bad" per se. Yet we're all here discussing this as if it's already decided that this data shouldn't be shared and I'm sitting here thinking "Wtf? Who asked me?". Ok, so the Tax firm I gave my personal info to put it on Google, okay. Will google see it? Sure. Is it on some DB on google? Sure. Do I care? No. We're watching the world burn right now with more pressing issues, and this whole thing seems so ridiculously academic and contrived.
- mcv 3y agoNot sure what's misleading about it. They shared that data through these analytics links, didn't they? And according to the article, Facebook then used it for targeted advertising. I don't see where you get that people are blaming the platform. It sounds to me that they're blaming the tax prep companies that shared the sensitive data.
- emodendroket 3y ago> I don't see where you get that people are blaming the platform. Other than when Senators referred to it as a shocking breach of privacy by "Big Tech" and the article includes a digression on Facebook's supposed long history of privacy issues, clearly implying this is another such incident?
- mcv 3y agoWell, they do. That's why those tax prep companies should be doubly careful about sharing sensitive data with them. And it was "by tax prep companies and by Big Tech firms", so they didn't put all the blame just on Google and Facebook.
- emodendroket 3y agoNobody said they put the blame "just" on Google and Facebook.
- jeffbee 3y agoIf I take your tax return and store it in my deposit box at the bank, it is misleading to say that I shared it with the bank, or the bank collected it. The letter from Sen. Warren that caused this press article blames Meta and Google for these events. It says "The Big Tech firms also appeared to act with stunning disregard for taxpayer privacy" even though Google and Meta had no agency in these matters.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y ago<< Google and Meta had no agency in these matters. I take issue with this statement. agency is defined as -- via google - as action or intervention, especially such as to produce a particular effect If google/meta creates a product like google analytics that is then used by third parties ( even if it is misused -- for various values of misused ), in itself, it is an action. You can say they were not actively involved ( and I do wonder about that, but I have no definitive proof one way or another ), but it is hard to argue they have no agency. It is an equivalent of 'look, we are only selling the thing that we also happen to completely control online and we have no control over how it is used'. It is not a great defense ( and it is very easy to portray negatively ).
- dfxm12 3y agoIt doesn't seem like anyone is saying this is the problem of Google Analytics or Pixel, but rather the problem of tax prep firms for storing the data in first place and perhaps meta for using this sensitive data.
- emodendroket 3y agoThe Senators demanding investigation and the article itself are both clearly implying Facebook has done something wrong. The accusation seems to be that Facebook used the data to target ads. I suspect that's true only in the sense that it went into the same generalized funnel all the URLs do and not that they're specifically parsing out this information, but I guess those details don't matter if your reputation stinks.
- davrosthedalek 3y agoHow do you know that they are not parsed out by Meta? The possibilities for this goes from collusion with the tax firms over somebody at Meta reverse engineering the coding to an automatic "AI" reverse engineering ("pattern discovery" Not sure if they do that but possibly?).
- emodendroket 3y agoI don’t “know” that which is why I said I “suspect” it rather than “know” it. But it seems like such an obviously foolhardy move with such marginal gain to deliberately seek to collect and analyze that data from tax prep firms that I have a hard time imagining them signing off on it.
- davrosthedalek 3y agoMy point is that they might not have to sign off on it. The signal for the ads might have been discovered by an algorithm without making it explicit to the management. I would not be surprised if google, meta and co don't have big ML codes that try to find signals to increase ad revenue, and they dump all data they have into it.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoIt is Google’s fault for creating a product that can be abused in such a way that would allow for these outsized and egregious invasions of individual privacy In every other engineering discipline you are required to understand the impacts and uses of what you build. This is what an “environmental impact study” is - and despite what people might think of how they are used - the core purpose and reason they are key to engineering is because second and third order effects are real, impactful and frankly mitigation costs a lot. Unfortunately, we never actually developed such a practice in software development outside of cases where hard engineering was leading such as in defense, nuclear or other very highly regulated, lethal, or martial industries.
- emodendroket 3y agoIs it Husqvarna’s fault if I use a chainsaw carelessly and amputate myself?
- hedora 3y agoIt depends. That’s the point. In the past, machinery didn’t have covers over what are now internal moving parts. The law changed that.
- emodendroket 3y agoYes but some tools which are useful and important are inherently dangerous to oneself or others. There is only so much you can do to make them safer before you have to make the operator assume responsibility for using them properly.
- aidanlister 3y agoThis argument can be extended to anything, which suggests it might not add any value to the discussion. - You make Microsoft Excel. Someone uses Excel to leak a million people’s PII. - You build shovels. Someone murdered someone with your shovel. - You build an analytics product, explicitly ban collecting PII in your EULA, someone does it anyway. It’s fun to be outraged and hating on GA is very in vogue at the moment, but this specific incident is just someone (yes, someone, not a nefarious company) using a popular tool incorrectly.
- plg 3y agoAgreed! “Shared” implies good natured oopsie. More likely it was _sold_
- gunapologist99 3y agoThe article states that the information was "shared" with Google and Meta via their respective pixels for ad-tracking purposes, but claims that only Meta parsed out that data and misused it. The original cited source is https://themarkup.org/pixel-hunt/2022/11/22/tax-filing-websites-have-been-sending-users-financial-information-to-facebook https://themarkup.org/pixel-hunt/2022/11/22/tax-filing-websi... and contains more details than the AP article (and was discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33753058 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33753058 )
- gruez 3y ago>but claims that only Meta parsed out that data and misused it. Can you quote the specific section for this claim? I skimmed the themarkup.org article and the closest thing I could find was this >Meta wins financially too. The company says it can use the data it gleans from tools like the pixel to power its algorithms, providing it insight into the habits of users across the internet. Which has a link to facebook's tos. That's not really indication of what they actually do, just legal ass covering.
- nojvek 3y ago"if Intuit put everyone's AGI in a Google Sheet." AGI here refers to Annual Gross Income, not Artificial General Intelligence. My brain skipped a beat because I assume Intuit had AGI but backtracked because you can't really put AGI in a Google Sheet. :shrugs:
- Centigonal 3y ago"I'm sorry, Dave, I'm afraid I can't make that deduction."
- maaarghk 3y agoI don't understand why you'd be confused after reading the original source[1]. The authors explain at length why they consider it to be Meta's problem, and it's not hard to understand - Meta make misleading claims about their own ability to detect and filter personal information. It also appears the detail sent was a lot less obfuscated than you indicate here. If you only got as far as the press release[2] then I can understand your view: > * Tax prep companies shared extraordinarily sensitive personal and financial information with Meta, which used the data for diverse advertising purposes > TaxAct, H&R Block, and TaxSlayer each revealed, in response to this Congressional inquiry, that they shared taxpayer data via their use of the Meta Pixel and Google’s tools. Although the tax prep companies and Big Tech firms claimed that all shared data was anonymous, the FTC and experts have indicated that the data could easily be used to identify individuals, or to create a dossier on them that could be used for targeted advertising or other purposes. This paragraph is woolly and does not appear to support the claim in the bullet point. But the full report has much strong wording on page 2: "Meta also confirmed that it used the data to target ads to taxpayers, including for companies other than the tax prep companies themselves, and to train Meta's own AI algorithms". The logic of this claim, via page 19, appears to be: Meta says if their sensitive information filtering algorithm detected personal information, the information would not have been used for advertising, and they'd have sent a notification to the tax prep firms. They also confirmed the negative case: if no notification was received by the tax prep firm, then no filtering of their data took place. Meta was asked to provide copies of notifications they had sent to the tax prep firms and they did not do so. So the assumption is that none were sent, therefore no filtering took place, and the data were used as a signal in the advertising algorithm. I don't find it to be an unequivocal confirmation, but the sources don't support your claim that this article is misleading or your claim that there's no reason to consider it a problem of the tech companies involved. [1] https://www.warren.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Attacks%20on%20Tax%20Privacy%20Report_7.12.2023.pdf https://www.warren.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Attacks%20on%20T... [2] https://www.warren.senate.gov/oversight/reports/in-new-report-senators-warren-wyden-lawmakers-reveal-massive-likely-illegal-breach-of-taxpayer-privacy-by-tax-prep-companies-with-meta_call-for-agencies-to-investigate-prosecute https://www.warren.senate.gov/oversight/reports/in-new-repor...