4 ms·
> "it is trying to protect the hard drives and data through fires of up to 1550F for 30 minutes and 10 feet of water for up to 72 hours." Trying. It does not l
by hulitu 3y ago
> "it is trying to protect the hard drives and data through fires of up to 1550F for 30 minutes and 10 feet of water for up to 72 hours."
Trying. It does not look fire proof to me, especially the power supply. Did they ever tried to submerge it in a pool for 72 hours. They forgot to say also if those specs are operating or nonoperating.
- tyn_ 3y agoThe review seems quite clear on that point, even from the line you quoted. It's protecting the hard drives, not the NAS. The electronics (including the external power supply) are not encased in the safe are -- only the drives are. > The concept is more that one can pull the drives out, put them in another Synology NAS, and be up and running quickly after a fire.
- jacquesm 3y agoEven if you do that you should never rely on those drives longer than it takes to pull the data off. And even then I'd advocate for an off-site mirror rather than to rely on drives surviving any kind of fire.
- gtirloni 3y agoYeah, I'm trying to imagine a scenario where this solution would be better than off-site. The only thing I can think of is CCTV footage that might be too heavy to transfer over slow links in remote locations.
- readthenotes1 3y agoI did not read any fire or water testing. It seems like a not very enthusiastic review...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ilyt 3y agoHave you tried reading the article before commenting?