5 ms·
I share the authors desire for there to be more programmers and that software will eat the world. However why do we need a Raspberry Pi? Can't you make softwar
by rmc 15y ago
I share the authors desire for there to be more programmers and that software will eat the world.
However why do we need a Raspberry Pi? Can't you make software with any computer (except recent things from Apple)? Or is it a case that RP, being so popular will get people talking about creating and playing with stuff?
- mvanga 15y agoI imagine the price being extremely low is a very useful factor when you are talking about giving every kid his own computer. With a Raspi, you can give your kid a decently powerful computer for around $100 (assuming you buy the keyboard, screen, mouse etc.).
- Maxious 15y agoJust like the computers of yore, the screen is the family TV. And USB keyboard/mouse are a couple of dollars second hand - I'd bet if UK school districts are anything like the ones I worked with in my youth, they have rooms filled with peripherals waiting to be recycled.
- mvanga 15y agoI had forgotten about the TV! I imagine a lot of people will go that route to save the money on a new monitor. Though, I think about the insane hours I spend tinkering with my computer when I was a kid and it makes me wonder how many parents would be happy to let their children go on tinkering for hours like that on the commong family screen!
- dazzawazza 15y agoThis is true but for a lot of parents there is one computer in the house and it's pretty precious, the kids can't 'fuck it up'. Now, with a rp, when a kid says "I'm gonna strap my computer to this servo, and that servo to some junk in the garage and throw it all off of the roof AND IT WILL FLY!" a few less parent will freak out and there is more of a chance we can all benefit from what ever is in this kids head..... and latterly smashed on his lawn :) There are a lot of ideas in kids heads that just don't see the light of day.
- husky 15y agoGreat comment - such experimentation is what creates the best tech and giving kids the ability to try ideas in their head is invaluable
- rmc 15y agoYes experimentation is great. but, many teenagers already have a laptop (or parents have their own). Surely there's lots of people with 2+ computers.
- dazzawazza 15y agoYeah there are lots but even the poorest can afford a RP, which is more and more is better. Even the richest parents would think twice about allowing little alice to throw her laptop off the roof. As a kid that grew up without a lot of stuff and my parents struggled to get me my first computer (Oric 16k). It changed my life. I think the RP will change more lives and open up more avenues to genuinely poor kids who want to experiment. Great ideas are not just generated by middle/upper class kids, us working class kids have great ideas too. I realise this is a great generalisation and we live in a 'class-less society' and money goes up as well as down and some kids will indeed use RP to record their sisters undressing and some kids will try and snort their RP up their nose BUT it's a genuine opportunity for ALL kids and I endorse it.
- DanBC 15y agoKids who do have their own laptops available are going to be gently hampered by choice-paralysis. What programming language do they learn[1]? Where do they start? What do they need to get to start? They're also going to be gently hampered by having various incompatibilities - the programming environment will cause some stuff to not compile and while that's a great learning experience it's not what you want someone to be faced with on their first "Hello World" example. Note that all those home computers that people started on, typing listings from magazines, did not have those problems. And advanced learners are going to be gently impeded by the OS not letting them get access to the hardware. I made a simple DA converter out of resistors soldered to a D25, which I used with NO$GB emulator. Building that DA was useful for me, and seeing the data lines on the D25 made the concept a lot more real. I guess this is possible under Linux or OSX or Windows but it's harder than just selecting addresses and sending data to them. [1] My answer to those questions is to just use "Learn Python the Hard Way"; perhaps having a version tailored for young people and the Raspberry PI. Once they've worked their way through that they have the confidence to start choosing editors etc.
- evilvoidhamster 15y agowe can get deeper with the ARm processor more easily than with x86. This isn't just about javascript or other High High level languages (although that is important), its about the fundamentals of programming and computer science.
- rbarooah 15y agoJust to clear this up, there is nothing at all about the 'recent things from apple' that prevents kids using them to make software, except for price. In fact I'd say that Apple's stack is outstanding for this purpose because it goes all the way from the very top (high level support for multi-touch) all the way to the very bottom (arm assembly), with an IDE and remote debugging at every level. I think there is also a psychological advantage to the Apple stack for passionate young programmers - they aren't programming a toy. For this purpose though, it is vastly more expensive than the alternatives.
- rmc 15y agothere is nothing at all about the 'recent things from apple' that prevents kids using them to make software, except for price If all you own is an iPad, Apple don't let you run software tools on it.
- rbarooah 15y agoHere is a great programming environment you can run with only an iPad: http://twolivesleft.com/Codea/ http://twolivesleft.com/Codea/ If you mean that you can't develop native apps using only an iPad, that is true. For that you need to buy other tools (e.g. a Mac mini), which is why I said it was an expensive option.