3 ms·
> An alternative approach to post-hoc rationalization is to look into the factors that contributed to a particular outcome That's... 5 Why's. If that's not hap
by hinkley 3y ago
> An alternative approach to post-hoc rationalization is to look into the factors that contributed to a particular outcome
That's... 5 Why's. If that's not happening for your 5 Why's, you can try to start steering things more assertively. The worst 5 Why's I've ever encountered looked a bit like children wearing mommy's dress shoes. I've had pretty good luck railroading such milquetoast RCAs into something at least moderately productive. There's always one person with an agenda but in my experience most people seem relieved that anyone else wants the reins. You don't even have to be in charge, you just have to keep drawing attention back to the person with the most coherent comments.
You have a problem, what does it look like? Do we have other problems that look like this? Is there a concrete action we can take to reduce the impact of this problem moving forward (ie, what aspect of the 4th why can we actually fix)? Are there other actions that would be more effective? Or more timely? Can we split the difference and half-fix a problem instead and circle back the next time it happens?
That's all 5 Why's. Or at least, the ones I attend.
- agentultra 3y agoI don't think it's necessarily wrong to use 5-Why's in one's analysis. I am suggesting that it should not be the only tool one uses. If success requires several contributing factors that are necessary and jointly sufficient to enable it, then failure should not be limited to a single root cause.