3 ms·
Good luck hiring someone who is merely unhappy in their current job. If someone is in a full-time job, it is hard enough to find time to go to interview. Good
by btilly 15y ago
Good luck hiring someone who is merely unhappy in their current job.
If someone is in a full-time job, it is hard enough to find time to go to interview. Good luck finding a free week to do a side project for you. They will self-select out of your selection pool, yet they are very valuable possibilities. Ditto for a probation period, why would someone with a job go work for 3 months for the possibility of maybe getting a different job?
Yet that said, I don't think this is bad advice. A company will see many candidates that could have worked out, the challenge is making sure you don't wind up with a promising looking dud. A high rate of false negatives are OK, so long as you don't get a false positive.
But it also isn't the only good way to do it.
- dustingetz 15y agothe challenges you describe are, i think, why networking is really the only viable way to find the best talent - self-selection can work in your favor, if you're doing it right. One of the leaders here in the Philadelphia tech community, Kyle Burton, talks about networking on HN here[1] - he is running a Clojure startup and has had little difficulty hiring due to the time he spent cultivating the local community. he hosts his own clojure meetup which it appears he can hire from at will. edit: i just emailed him to belatedly ask permission to quote him, maybe he will chime in here. "I was actively recruited to the team. I personally believe that this was because I made a conscious effort in the fall of 2008 to start being much more active in the community at large. I started doing more visibile things on the internet: a blog, putting up a sandbox on github. I also started speaking at local user groups (god bless them for listening to my first talks and my horrible, horrendous presentation skills). ... "By 'recruited into' I mean that not in the sense that either side used a recruiter. I mean I was approached through my network because of the effort I put into building the netowrk and the effort I put into building a personal brand (as slimy as that sounds, it is working). ... "Actively working at networking has been wonderful. I can't recommend it enough. I was involved in starting a "tech breakfast" meeting that takes place 1x a month. The local groups (esp volunteering to speak), the breakfast sessions, and buying people lunch (an hour of interesting conversation is totally worth the $10, and every time it has come back to me) has gone a long way to building a local network." [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2832571 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2832571
- jiggy2011 15y agoI agree, things like this often look like code for "we only want to hire 20something fresh out of college candidates"
- JonWood 15y agoI'm agreed on the week of work, since as you say, no one in a proper job is going to take a week of holiday to come and work for someone who may or may not employ them. Probation however is a standard clause on every UK employment contract I've seen, usually with a 3-6 month period, during which either side can get out without penalty if it isn't working out.