4 ms·
I would say that my view is closer to C, but instead of having criminal intent someone would have intent to do something regardless of the legality. >However,
by charcircuit 3y ago
I would say that my view is closer to C, but instead of having criminal intent someone would have intent to do something regardless of the legality.
>However, even C) is rebuffed by "the definition of criminal is fluid and changes over time; and there is little guarantee in the stickyness or aggreeableness of said change"
Which is why I believe it to be important for laws to not be retroactive. If someone is living somewhere which allows retroactive laws and wanted to do something then trying to find ways to hide your potentially criminal behavior could be desirable. I believe people should just be honest that they want to have their crimes be hidden to reduce their legal liability than to pretend that they just really like privacy as a concept or because they think privacy in a human right.
- dijit 3y agoInteresting thoughts; I think on a fundamental level there is something you misunderstand about privacy though. I genuinely do not engage in any criminal activities (that I am aware are criminal at least) - so I dont fully understand where the criminality angle comes from. However, consider the toilet: everyone basically knows whats going on in the toilet, some people do criminal things in the toilet, yet we give toilets doors & special stalls. This is what privacy is, a little comfort that you are not being watched while doing intimate or personal things. With the understanding that, yes, sometimes this comfort can lead to some people abusing it.
- DropInIn 3y agoHeres the blatant problem with the law changing without true justification: people plan around the laws and if a right is lost suddenly it would have life altering ramifications for more than a negligible volume of people.