5 ms·
Uh, we don’t necessarily need a great filter to not be constantly visited - we just need a lack of ‘cheat codes’ (like warp drives, wormholes, dirt cheap energy
by lazide 3y ago
Uh, we don’t necessarily need a great filter to not be constantly visited - we just need a lack of ‘cheat codes’ (like warp drives, wormholes, dirt cheap energy from magical fusion or zero point or whatever), combined with relatively short lived complex civilizations.
If no one can afford the trip (due to what we currently know of physics), or survive as a complex civilization long enough (100k+ years), then… you see what you see right now.
- dontupvoteme 3y agoIf you're talking about sending live people, absolutely If you're talking about sending alien drones, the light mass and lack of having to keep them alive makes energy requirements a lot lower, but they'd probably just be scouting us (if not trying to kill us) so we wouldn't be able to detect them
- dougmwne 3y agoAnd this is why I suspect AGI superintelligence is impossible. A bio civilization will never reach us. An AGI will reach us rapidly.
- revscat 3y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/aliens/comments/14rnjoa/from_the_late_2000s_to_the_mid2010s_i_worked_as_a/ https://www.reddit.com/r/aliens/comments/14rnjoa/from_the_la...
- lazide 3y agoConsidering no human object has yet to leave the solar system (meaningfully), and we’ve nearly wiped ourselves out several times just in recent memory - that’s still in the realm of pure fantasy. There is no evidence yet that anything we can construct (or a near peer) could make it to another system intact enough to know it had arrived, let alone DO anything regardless of the form any intelligence takes or how it is packaged. Hell, as a species we still struggle to land probes on mars and Venus. And they don’t have to do anything but send data back. Getting a toehold on a random solar system, or even arriving and taking pictures and sending them back is so many orders of magnitudes harder to do based on what we know now it’s essentially impossible. Even if we had a ‘fast forward’ button. Hopefully we’ll find something out that we’re currently missing, but as of yet we have no reason to believe it exists.
- TheCleric 3y agoNot sure what "meaningfully" is supposed to mean here, but both Voyager probes have gone passed the heliopause and are outside our solar system from that perspective.
- lazide 3y ago"However, if we define our solar system as the Sun and everything that primarily orbits the Sun, Voyager 1 will remain within the confines of the solar system until it emerges from the Oort cloud in another 14,000 to 28,000 years." [https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/in-depth/ https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/in-depth/] "The twin Voyagers are the only man-made objects to have entered interstellar space. However, while they have left the heliosphere, they have not yet left the boundary of the Solar System which is considered to be the outer edge of the Oort Cloud." [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heliosphere#Heliopause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heliosphere#Heliopause] [https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-voyager-2-probe-enters-interstellar-space https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-voyager-2-probe-en...] It's still in the area of things that primarily orbit the sun, even if it is no longer in the 'atmosphere' or 'shade' of the Sun (aka the heliopause, which is what was being used for PR purposes). And it's nowhere near anything which isn't orbiting the sun, and nowhere near 'not being in' the area of things orbiting the sun. So meaningfully, it's still in the solar system, and will be for a very long time. It's just out of the nice part. Distance wise, Voyager 1 (the furthest) is ~ 22 light hours away, or .02% of a light year - after travelling for 45 years. Proxima Centauri, the closest known star to us is 4.25 light years away. It would take ~ 73,000 years at Voyagers blistering pace (38,000 mph) to reach it, and there is essentially zero chance we could keep contact with it or it would be functional even 1/10th of that time - it's RTG is already nearly dead, and with a ~ 87 year half life, it would be a miracle if it even lasted another 50-100 years.
- dontupvoteme 3y agoVoyager was meant to take pictures of objects in our celestial sphere, if instead we were in a race to, for instance, yeet our stuff faster than the soviets towards Proxima Centauri, everything would have been different.
- dougmwne 3y agoYou just proposed a great filter, short lived civilizations. If civilizations lasted for billions of years or their AGIs did the same, we’d have a lot higher chance of them expanding to fill the galaxy and converting the surface of all 8 planets and major asteroids into AGI probes and compute.
- lazide 3y agoThat’s not what I’d consider a great filter in the usual usage. We’ve only had ~10k years of recorded history. If we can’t make a meaningful dent somewhere outside the solar system in another 10x that amount of time, I doubt we (or anyone) ever would. A civilization doesn’t have to survive a billion years (do you know how long that actually is?) to not be ‘short lived’.
- dougmwne 3y agoI would define short lived as the difference between dying out in a local star cluster or continuing to expand till the heat death of the universe. A long-lived and expansionary civilization will eventually reach us, even if it takes 1k years to hop from star to star. A short lived civilization will never reach us.
- lazide 3y agoNone of the situations you’re giving are based entirely off longevity - they use longevity as a factor of another equation. A billion year old civilization that isn’t expansionary will never reach us either. Or one that doesn’t want to spend the energy ($$$) if other cheap energy forms we’ve speculated aren’t possible or as inexpensive/portable as would be needed. They could just as easily be happy being billion year old zen masters, and we’d never know - even if they had warp drives. They’d still exist though, and if we ever wanted to find them I guess we’d be able to do so. But we’d never know about them proactively.
- cthalupa 3y agoSomething like a fleet of von Neumann probes could expand across the entirety of the galaxy in a million years or so, and wouldn't care if the original civilization had long since flamed out. Which is long time by our standards, but not too long on the cosmological scale. In theory there should have been lots of habitable places where life could have arisen in our galaxy long enough in the past that the whole place could be "colonized" in this manner. Of course, there could be plenty of these floating around our solar system and we wouldn't know. They could be quite small and the solar system is quite big, and most of the proposed use cases for a civilization wanting to do this would not require it be in constant contact, so they might not even be broadcasting on anything resembling a frequent basis. But in general there are a lot of theoretical technosignatures that we think we should be able to see if there was technological advanced life in the galaxy. (Should be able to see in that it is possible with our current technology - not that we would conclusively have seen it by this point.)
- lazide 3y agoIt’s a nice idea in theory, but we’ve seen no evidence Von Neumann probes are even possible, or that any civilization would consider them worth investing in. If you do the math, unless there are the aforementioned ‘cheat codes’, they frankly just don’t pencil out as worthwhile. No FTL/subspace? No ‘infinite cheap energy’ hack? No ‘infinite self replicating yet controllable builder of anything’ molecule? No way to propagate, no way to energize, and no way to communicate at any real scale over the distances involved. Even gigawatt power, high efficiency, high precision aimed lasers aren’t going to have much luck at light year distances, and nothing is going to be useful for two way communication. It’s easy to speculate of course, but like ‘grey goo’ it runs up against real issues with thermodynamics and physics if we stop and think about it much. Worth investigating options of course, or talking about, but if physics is what it seems to be so far, that would perfectly explain the lack of us seeing them - they’re not useful/practical/worth the expense for anyone.
- cthalupa 3y agoWorthwhile to invest in I think is the bigger question - from a practical 'can we build a self replicating probe fleet that would eventually cover the galaxy', there's at least evidence that it's possible in the next hundred years or so. http://www.rfreitas.com/Astro/ComparisonReproNov1980.htm http://www.rfreitas.com/Astro/ComparisonReproNov1980.htm https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2005/2005.12303.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2005/2005.12303.pdf In general I do think it makes sense to not just contemplate interstellar visitors as living things making the trek or biological civilizations expanding, but there's a wide variety of artificial ~things~ that could end up in our solar system for whatever reason.