4 ms·
So it's kinda like Couchsurfing.com and Warmshowers, but expensive ($100/yr) and only for vanlifers? Interesting. I like the community peer to peer model, but
by solardev 3y ago
So it's kinda like Couchsurfing.com and Warmshowers, but expensive ($100/yr) and only for vanlifers? Interesting.
I like the community peer to peer model, but it kinda feels exploitative to put an expensive business layer on top of it. What does the $100/yr provide that Couchsurfing's $30/yr doesn't, aside from a feeling of exclusivity? Or is that the point, to weed out poor vanlifers and allow only rich vacationers to swap hosting with each other?
- sfpotter 3y ago> Or is that the point, to weed out poor vanlifers and allow only rich vacationers to swap hosting with each other? I'm gonna go with "yes" purely based on the website's design.
- solardev 3y agoIt does have that country club, "no need to park with the peasants" vibe to it, doesn't it?
- mrb 3y ago"rich vacationers" ? Most American adults can afford $100/year. Edit: I'll even add: most american adults spend $100 per month, not per year, on frivolous stuff. Fast food. Cable TV. Unnecessary high-end phones (instead of mid-range phones). All these people could definitely afford $100/year.
- kevinsundar 3y agoYou can't use land camp if you don't own a home / property that has parking space and restrooms. At least after your 3 free stays are done.
- mrb 3y agoCorrect, but solardev was criticizing the $100/yr price, specifically.
- jmspring 3y agoAnd if you own a home, $100 is NOTHING compared to all costs incurred.
- notahacker 3y agoOr put another way, you pay at least $33/night for the right to park a van in one or more undisclosed locations in California for a maximum of three nights. Not sure how that compares with local campsites cost-wise, but it isn't quite free. Any additional benefit you may be able to obtain is contingent upon other people wanting to park on your lawn for an equivalent number of nights first, which implies you're probably not in the can't afford a campsite bracket, is probably more hassle than paying for a campsite, and isn't much use if you're looking to stop for four nights somewhere in the near future... Other sites charge less for the right to stay 365 days a year at thousands of actual photographed locations without being a California homeowner with parking space, and waive the fee if you host.
- solardev 3y agoI think that's a pretty privileged viewpoint. That's $100/year of disposable income for maybe a parking spot where you want to go, maybe available when you want to go. That's definitely not a trivial dollar amount for something like that, especially when there are free alternatives (strip mall parking lots, rest stops, federal lands, moving between neighborhoods, etc.). Then there's the question of being able to offer a designated parking spot (hosting) in exchange for staying credits. Paid private parking, especially extra spots, is an absurd luxury in much of the country, for many people. I knew many people -- climbers, travelers, dirtbaggers, backpackers -- who really wanted to see the public lands that they partially own but could not afford to travel in luxury, people who ate ramen and rice and beans for months just to be able to afford to see the lands. There are also people who live in campers and vans because they can't afford rent. That $100 could definitely go to better uses. If $100 is nothing to you, perhaps you're the kind of traveler this website is targeting. It's definitely not for everyone. I've met many amazing people on Couchsurfing and Warmshowers, which (at the time) were totally free and still today are much cheaper. The vast majority of the people I hosted were very poor but very well traveled, with stories to tell and friendships across the world. Very few of the rich people I've met have had the same experiences to share. Hosting them was a privilege, and not something I would've wanted to charge them for even if I could. I also met very interesting hosts traveling the same way, because at the end day doing that becomes way more relational and way less transactional -- the opposite of luxury travel.
- jmspring 3y ago$100/year, $0.27/day is not in the realm of privilege. The groups you mention spend more than that a year to upgrade gear/etc. I call bollocks on this.
- solardev 3y agoI think this is missing the point. It's not "Can I afford $100 for a year's worth of travel", it's that communities have been sharing hosting/staying for a long time already, for free or nearly free. Then suddenly a new company shows up, offers the same service, but now wants to charge hosts and guests $100/yr for doing the same thing as before. Why should they pay that? What does the new company offer? FWIW, it is a genuine question, and depending on the answer could make the service actually very valuable. For example (only): * If they manually vet each member not just with a basic ID check (ID.me etc.) but also with a background check and a Zoom interview, or otherwise improve community trust and relationships * If they provide a built-in calendar/scheduling system and provide support for last-minute cancellations, rebookings, etc. * If they provide vastly superior UX or support compared to Couchsurfing and Warmshowers * If they provide support for international travelers, especially for accidents, medical issues, translations, whatever. But so far this seems to be within California only. But from their website it's not clear that such value-adds are being done, so then the question is not whether $100/yr is affordable, it's what $100/yr gives you that $30/yr does not. If you're rich, that's not a big deal. If you're poor, that $70 a year DOES make a difference.
- isatty 3y agoNot personal but I absolutely hate your edit. Frivolous stuff that you mentioned is _important_ for mental health and hence not.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoTherapy is important for mental health. Exercise is important for mental (and physical) health. Cable and McDonald's isn't. I don't think I've met a single millennial in the past year that cooks their own food. I'm worried for them.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoCouchsurfing's downfall was lack of money (and incredibly poor use of funds) that led to the sale to the bizarre monetizing and "creepy engagement" scheme that ruined it. I would pay $300/yr if it would restore the Couchsurfing community and original site. If this $100 site led to the kind of community we used to have, it's a bargain. But it's not clear yet whether they will foster a community.
- solardev 3y agoI sadly stopped hosting a few years ago. What happened to the community/site? I must've missed that part?
- throwaway892238 3y agoThey killed the useful forums, made the login page a "dashboard" so useless you had to bookmark other pages to remember how to get to them, made a bunch of unrelated sections nobody wanted, increased font sizes so you couldn't fit much on the page and thus finding useful information got worse, ignored feature requests, refused all offers of volunteer tech work, introduced a "chat with random people nearby" that led to 30 dudes trying to hook up with the only female in town, and added fees to verify or send couch requests. All of which led to an exodus of any of the active users to random Facebook groups. Now the site is mainly for people to try and hook up while traveling, there's no community to teach people to act hospitably, profiles are garbage, and few people host anyone but the opposite sex. There are still some good people who use it the right way, but way more who don't. It's arduous, inconvenient and sketchy now.
- solardev 3y agoOh damn. That's a real shame! Is there any real hope left to save it and bring back the community? Is it too late? I wish I paid more attention :/ Had I known this was happening I would've done more... seems like people tried, to no avail? It's really sad. It was such a fantastic resource and I really wish I could still host (my partner's not too into it... maybe I'll try to convince her if there's any more community left TO host).
- i_am_jl 3y ago>only for vanlifers? Couldn't work for a vanlifer, only an RVer. Vanlifers don't have property where they can host.
- jstarfish 3y agoIt's exploitative at any price. Someone is bearing the cost of maintaining a physical campsite to offer something out of goodwill. Charging people for access to it is scummy. It's like those parking scams at stadiums. All the lots are full, but some dude in a reflective vest starts directing traffic into a private lot, collects $40 per car and disappears into the night. After the game, everyone finds their cars booted/ticketed. Next up: a subscription service to borrow books for free.
- nomel 3y ago> Charging people for access to it is scummy. I see it as paying for a moderation/review system. It also acts as a filter that many might appreciate, helping identify "serious van-lifers only".
- ratg13 3y agoA moderator/review system that has no description other than “zero tolerance” It reads to me like the first person to complain can boot the other person off the site.. hardly worth $100
- jstarfish 3y agoRight, but it's arbitrage for something maintained at someone else's expense. If you're making money off of something supported by charity, you're being exploitative. Business as usual for the SV crowd, I guess. Next Up: SoupFree, a subscription service that helps you score a $0 meal at the nearest soup kitchen.
- soared 3y agoThe $100/yr cost in undoubtedly cheaper than owning a parking spot and a bathroom in California!