2 ms·
>Health insurance company executives are though, aren't they? Their compensation is the "administrative overhead." Yes, and considering they health insurance c
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
>Health insurance company executives are though, aren't they? Their compensation is the "administrative overhead."
Yes, and considering they health insurance company executives are not all the richest people in the US, there must exist some pressure to contain their compensation.
>once you take lowering claims costs off the table as a way to make more money.
This is a pretty big assumption. Surely, UHC/Elevance/CVS/Cigna/Humana risk losing clients if they let their costs go up compared to competitors, and hence their premiums go up, and then a competitor offers their customers lower premiums.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Yes, and considering they health insurance company executives are not all the richest people in the US, there must exist some pressure to contain their compensation. Sure there is. But they're also not poor, so there must be some pressure to keep shareholders from paying them minimum wage. And if they make the shareholders more money, the shareholders will be willing to pay them more. If the way they do that is by making the same margin on a higher cost base, that also allows the shareholders to pay them more. So the incentives all line up to have higher medical costs. > Surely, UHC/Elevance/CVS/Cigna/Humana risk losing clients if they let their costs go up, and hence their premiums go up, and then a competitor offers their customers lower premiums. But their competitors have the same incentives. Suppose you could lower your costs. One thing you could do is keep charging the same amount of money and just make more money, but now that's prohibited. So already we have a disincentive to lower costs right there. Maybe we don't care about this one, but this one is often combined with the second one, and the incentive to achieve the cost reduction is what enables them to do the one we actually like. Which is to lower prices to try to get more customers. So let's say they lower their premiums by 20% and that gets them 10% more customers. If their absolute profit per customer stays the same, now they're making 10% more money -- great. But now their absolute profit per customer isn't allowed to stay the same. It has to go down by the 20% their costs went down. Meanwhile the lower premiums only got them 10% more customers, so they're losing money on net. Why would they do that?