3 ms·
Spacing in the GUI seems to be a power user vs beginner tradeoff. Beginners like big UI's with a few large buttons with nice big icons clearly illustrating wha
by londons_explore 3y ago
Spacing in the GUI seems to be a power user vs beginner tradeoff.
Beginners like big UI's with a few large buttons with nice big icons clearly illustrating what they do.
Experts like to fit as much functionality in as possible, so want keyboard shortcuts and millions of buttons.
The logical thing seems to be some slider to adjust 'UI density' that defaults to beginner mode, but can be slid on a per-app basis. How hard can it be?
- js8 3y agoGNOME 2 used to have a choice for toolbars: icons, icons & text, text.
- anthk 3y agoXFCE still has it. And any GTK2/3 config tool such as lxappearance.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoAs did every Cocoa app on macOS.
- jwells89 3y agoSome still do, even if it's fallen out of fashion.
- bandrami 3y agoHuh. In my experience experts fill their screen with one application at a time and turn off its menus and toolbars.
- bityard 3y agoI don't run applications fullscreen and have no desire to turn off menus and toolbars either. I guess I'll never be an expert.
- MR4D 3y agoIf you look at the pictures from the link, the Windows 9 screenshot has a much better use of space. The two screenshots have almost exactly the same functionality, but much worse use of space. So while I agree with your comments, I still hate the one on the right because it makes my eyes jump around all over. The first, by contrast, has a much smoother eye flow over the controls. This is something most people don't understand when doing UI design, and is somewhat independent from the amount of stuff on the screen.
- hot_gril 3y agoWord kinda has this with the ability to toggle additional toolbars. But the real power users will know all the shortcuts.
- actuallyalys 3y agoMaking a UI that is usable at multiple density levels, especially if it has to adapt to different screen sizes and allow for other customization, seems like a big jump up in complexity. It might be worth it, but I'm not surprised few apps do it.