3 ms·
Why does everyone want to turn github in to gamified social media. The resulting software is the achievement not sone bullshit badge.
by bawolff 3y ago
Why does everyone want to turn github in to gamified social media.
The resulting software is the achievement not sone bullshit badge.
- flangola7 3y agoAwards are powerfully gratifying and motivational, for some of us especially so. Symbolism is present in every civilization of every era for a reason.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Awards are powerfully gratifying and motivational I think this is true but only if they're not common and they come from your peers. But I'm no psychologist, so I'm really only asserting what's true for me, not for everyone.
- reaperducer 3y agoThe resulting software is the achievement not sone bullshit badge. GitHub needs a Participation Badge.
- woodruffw 3y agoThis is, in the most basic sense, what the "user contributions" visualization on GitHub is.
- naikrovek 3y agobecause these achievements are potentially interesting metadata about your work. no one writes software for metadata. people write software, they push it to GitHub, and GitHub gives them achievements which may provide a fraction of a second of amusement. let people enjoy themselves a little, sheesh.
- reaperducer 3y agono one writes software for metadata They didn't used to because there was no incentive to do anything but a good job. Now there is an incentive to accumulate metadata. And just like thumbs on Facebook or points on StackOverflow, it will be gamed. It will be trolled. All you've done is take the incentive of "earn a good reputation by publishing quality work" and open the platform to people who only care about "Ooh, shiny pieces of flair!"
- naikrovek 3y agoI think you are dramatically overestimating the number of people who will do this. I also think that you are dramatically underestimating the transparency of activity optimized for metrics. Those that do this will reveal this behavior by virtue of the nature of the behavior itself. Dammit, it's OK for people to like stuff, even if you don't like that stuff. You don't like it! FINE! Others do, so let them live their own life, please.
- swozey 3y agoWho cares if 1% of people "game" it? Do you think people are actually looking up lists of achievements outside of gag websites like this and getting jealous that someone else has XYZ achievement to the point that they'll game the system themselves to get that achievement? And if they do, so what? So maybe 1% of people do that. We should nuke it for the other 99% who literally just push code into a repo, go to their profile randomly and see that they've earned a new badge? I have maybe 4-5 badges and I have literally no idea what the next one I'm closest to getting is. I don't even know what badges I'm missing. But it's still cool to me to see a new one show up.
- lucumo 3y ago> > no one writes software for metadata > They didn't used to because there was no incentive to do anything but a good job. Whenever I'm leaving a job, I keep a look-out for opportunities to change lines that rarely change. Things like doctype declarations, blank lines, closing braces, stuff like that. If I can change them, my name is memorialized longer in the `git blame` of projects. People will find ways to gamify everything. It's quite often a release valve for stress or boredom.
- TremendousJudge 3y agoThis is a joke website. The person who made it was making a joke.
- pc86 3y agoNo you don't understand we're engineers this is Serious Business and can only be conducted Seriously!
- swozey 3y agoWhy do tens of millions of video gamers work to get to 100% completion and various goofy achievements in their games? Why does Spotify Rewind get posted every year? Some of us find it fun and neat to see certain things/statistics we've achieved/ruined over time.
- bawolff 3y agoBut life is not a game. You cannot get 100% completion of creating open source software. These statistics (as well as the real githu badges) are bad and not correlated with what the whole point of it all is.
- lagniappe 3y agoI find myself wondering what the point of it all is. If anybody knows, holler.
- swozey 3y agoThere is no way that you can objectively state that "These statistics are bad." These badges literally do not affect my life at all. Nor do they affect probably 99% of github users other than being an interesting thing to look at when they accidentally click the profile button. I posted a screenshot on how to disable them if you'd like to. What is the "whole point of it all?" Who are you to determine that, anyway? Maybe the point of it for some people is to code and have fun :)
- jackson1442 3y agoyou can turn them off on your profile within settings if you dislike them that much.
- JohnFen 3y agoI'm 100% with you in that this "gamify everything" thing sets my teeth on edge. But this can easily be ignored. Let the kids have their fun.