5 ms·
I'm wondering how these smash room businesses address the liability for injuries? Not only hazards of batteries. I used a sledgehammer and related tools as a
by neilv 3y ago
I'm wondering how these smash room businesses address the liability for injuries?
Not only hazards of batteries. I used a sledgehammer and related tools as a kid, without lasting injury, but I wonder whether some adult city office worker suddenly swinging a sledgehammer one day, without prior conditioning, has a significant risk of quickly pulling/tearing something.
And on something like a plastic printer especially, I suspect you'd get "chaotic" behavior unfamiliar to many as they strike it, which initially seems innocuous, and could lead to shrapnel injury when it's suddenly not.
The liability risk makes this choice of example customer funny...
> Islas and two classmates were celebrating the end of their law school exams at Bay Area Smash Room,
Online, I've heard local apartment landlords say they don't want law school students as tenants, because they think the law student will be very assertive about their rights, and even actually want to go to court just for the experience. :) (Besides being illegal housing discrimination, it's not fair, since I've known a poorer law student in town who quietly endured an awful below-market apartment, but it remains.)
Do these smash room businesses have a really good waiver that would not only stand up in court, but keep it from getting very expensive merely going to court? Do they have insurance against customer injuries? Do they go out of business the first time there's a major injury? Will an LLC or other corp. shield personal assets?
- gruez 3y ago> I'm wondering how these smash room businesses address the liability for injuries? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assumption_of_risk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assumption_of_risk
- neilv 3y agoWhat does that idea mean in practice for these businesses? (I'm not a lawyer, and my understanding is that law doesn't work like computer programmers think it does.)
- blamazon 3y agoUsually (in USA) all customers are presented an acknowledgement/waiver at the door that spells out all the risks involved in the activity. Typically, to be permitted into the activity area you have to sign this document stating that you acknowledge the risks, and knowingly waive (discard) your right to sue the operator if you hurt yourself. These are mostly foolproof in transferring liability to the customer but they're sometimes phrased to imply you can't sue the operator if anything at all bad happens, which is usually not true - it's usually not possible to waive gross negligence. The particulars of what can and can't be waived vary state by state, in the USA. And yes, they usually carry insurance against such things, which is typically priced according to the strength of the waiver and lack of negligence on-site. Injuries at such waiver-gated locations are usually not business-ending or Top Golf never would have taken off the way it did... but at Top Golf scale you can be sure they have retained really good lawyers. Here's an example of such a document: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5a50f094268b96e867707e40/t/5b9099b10e2e72d0f6263f8e/1536203186170/Smashroom+Participant+Agreement.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5a50f094268b96e867707...
- neilv 3y agoWhat does that mean in practice? Does that mean if someone gets injured and they try to file a lawsuit, the clerk laughs in their face, and tells them to go away, before the defendant incurs any costs at all? Does it mean that the judge dismisses the case after only five figures of initial legal costs by defendant? Does it mean probably a settlement? (And maybe the settlement is smaller because the victim did sign something?) Does the victim signing something hardly matter, because they can show some other legal principle was in play (e.g., something involving negligence or recklessness, or some other law violated)? Does insurance cover it, and if so, what happens to rates or the policy continuing to exist? Etc.
- blamazon 3y agoThere's so many variables in play that it's difficult to speak universally on it. Every case is unique, there is relevant case law, different state laws, etc. Everything you said is a possibility - I would say off the cuff that it generally hinges on the scale of negligence and harm - consider these the X and Y axes of a graph where the Z axis is whether the clerk laughs at you, whether a judge dismisses it pre-trial, whether it goes to trial, if a settlement can be negotiated. Die or lose a limb? Stakes go up for sure. Sometimes insurance will pay all the legal/settlement costs, sometimes they won't, sometimes a business will have to negotiate to avoid a rate hike (we did x, y, and z to avoid this liability and minimize the settlement) and sometimes the insurance policy does vanish.
- mistersquid 3y ago> Online, I've heard local apartment landlords say they don't want law school students as tenants, because they think the law student will be very assertive about their rights, and even actually want to go to court just for the experience. :) (Besides being illegal housing discrimination[…] A bit OT, but wanted to note it's not illegal in the US to discriminate against prospective tenants because of employment or lack of employment as long as that discrimination is not related to membership in a protected class (gender, race, religion, disability, medical condition, etc,). [0] [0] https://prioritycommerce.com/resource-center/can-you-deny-prospective-tenants-based-on-their-jobs/#:~:text=Whatever%20reason%20you%20have%20for https://prioritycommerce.com/resource-center/can-you-deny-pr...,
- adrianmonk 3y ago> illegal housing discrimination Ethics aside, I'm not sure it's actually illegal in the US. Discrimination is only banned for protected classes, and I don't think those include field of study or work. Nationally[1], the classes are race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. Some states have additional protected classes[2], but I don't think they include this. --- [1] https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/fair_housing_equal_opp/fair_housing_act_overview https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/fair_housing_equal_opp/f... [2] https://lawatlas.org/datasets/state-fair-housing-protections-1498143743 https://lawatlas.org/datasets/state-fair-housing-protections...