3 ms·
Yes, that paper is not very convincing. Because we know for sure that more plants have been fossilized without being decomposed, it is certain that either the
by adrian_b 3y ago
Yes, that paper is not very convincing.
Because we know for sure that more plants have been fossilized without being decomposed, it is certain that either the plants were growing faster or after death they were decomposed slower or there were some phenomena that caused the frequent burial of the dead plants before being decomposed.
The last cause is implausible as an explanation for something that had a duration of more than one hundred million years and which never happened later.
Maybe the plants were growing faster, due to a higher content of carbon dioxide in the air, but that is not enough for a quantitative explanation, especially because if efficient decomposers had existed, their population size would have increased to match the available food. The decomposition must also have been much slower than today.
So there is little doubt that the wood was decomposed much slower than today. What is much less certain, and this is the only part of this research paper that may be correct, is that lignin was the culprit. Perhaps the fungi of Carboniferous and Permian already had all the digestive enzymes of today, but all of them were less optimized than the modern enzymes, so the wood decomposition speed was lower than today.