3 ms·
While I agree with you entirely, I'll propose an adjustment to the reason for this problem in the case of the UK: When the government is ideologically opposed
by vidarh 3y ago
While I agree with you entirely, I'll propose an adjustment to the reason for this problem in the case of the UK:
When the government is ideologically opposed to ensuring sufficient public oversight, quality of services drops.
The problem in the UK is not merely privatisation, but privatisation in a way that privatises profits, often socialises losses, and that substitutes dealing with crises after the fact over strong oversight during, because of a string of governments that have not just been opposed to government ownership, but that has been opposed to regulation.
You could strip away the profit motive by making these all non-profit stakeholder led organisations of some sort, and you'd still have a massive problem because of the lack of proper oversight.
Fix the oversight issue and maybe some degree of privatisation would work (though I agree many of these services should still not be operated with a profit motive), but the double whammy of weak oversight and privatisation is disastrous.
- scrlk 3y agoDieter Helm recently wrote an article about scrapping the current water privatisation model, without re-nationalisation: https://dieterhelm.co.uk/regulation-utilities-infrastructure/time-to-pull-the-plug-on-the-water-privatisation-model/ https://dieterhelm.co.uk/regulation-utilities-infrastructure...
- anonymousDan 3y agoThe problem is that even if one government were able to fix the oversight issue, its hard to see how subsequent governments can be prevented from ripping up the oversight (e.g. under the rubric of 'removing red tape'). Even if you look at the most likely incoming government, they are reluctant to get rid of the water companies due to cost. Perhaps what is needed is some mechanism whereby the threat of re-nationalisation can be enforced at minimum cost to the taxpayer.
- vidarh 3y agoIt is a problem largely created by granting them property rights instead of franchises or operating agreements. In a democracy we can never remove the risk of the next government messing it up, but as long as they grant time limited or restricted contracts the opportunity for reversal is there. Which, incidentally, the cynic in me would suggest is the reason for why e.g. the water privatisation was done the way it was. Compare to the train privatisation, where after the failure of Railtrack brought the infra itself back under government control, time limited franchises means that the government can at least regain control over time at low cost by simply ending the issuing of new franchises (and where the government have operated many franchises for various lengths of time due to outright failures of the franchise-holders to meet their obligations). You can even see it as allowing for shifting governments to change their mind without it becoming big all or nothing decisions (though the original franchise model is utterly messed up in how it aligns the incentives). To be clear: I think the rail privatisation was also an utter disaster, but it's current incarnation is not nearly as bad with the water companies - largely, incidentally, because large early failures like with Railtrack ended up with the undoing of some of the worst parts of it. It's still shit, though.
- toyg 3y agoThey are both ridiculous propositions. There cannot be any meaningful competition where 99% of the involved activity is effectively fixed (water pipes and plants, rail tracks, rolling stock, even the ticketing system now). It's all an ideological play supported by big money.
- vidarh 3y agoIndeed, but the water privatisation is as things currently stands (but only because Railtrack crashed and burned so we're already rid of that abomination) worse in the sense that there's no automatic exit mechanism because the water companies own the infrastructure. The rail franchises at least expire so the "cheap" out is to just let them run their course. But when the best you can say about one over the other is that it's cheaper to get out of it, not getting into it in the first place would've been preferable.
- debok 3y agoWeak oversight with nationalisation is even more disastrous. With a profit motive, the utility is at least incentivised to deliver the service so that they can get paid. If you have government-owned utlity with weak oversight, there is no incentive to even deliver the service. Look at what is happening with South Africa's power utility (and other State Owned Enterprises like their post office and national airline) as a great example of what happens to a public enterprise with no oversight.
- vidarh 3y agoWith nationalisation you can at least vote out the people who mismanage it. Privatisation makes this harder because you run into all kinds of issues with taking them over without paying market rates that acts as a massive barrier. E.g. this was a major factor in the arguments against Labour's 2017 and 2019 election manifestos in the UK, because the costs of buying out the private providers vs. the drastic risk to the economy of sending the signal that UK companies are at risk of uncompensated takeovers by the government were both used to hammer them with. But yes, you need strong oversight either way. > With a profit motive, the utility is at least incentivised to deliver the service so that they can get paid. I don't really agree with this. Semi-monopolised privatised providers only care to deliver service to the level where they maximise their return on investment. This is why we've seen multiple train operating companies collapse in the UK, because they were low capital to set up and bid on terms designed to let their owners extract as much as possible, without care for whether or not they'd remain viable, because until Virgin and Stagecoach faced outright bans on participating in bids for some new franchises there appeared to be no consequence. Worst case you'd just start a new one. It's also why we're seeing Thames Water fail to address a network of pipes that leaks an astonishing proportion of the supply because while you're right in as much as they've had to deliver service to consumer, they've not been incentivised to deliver the service to society as a whole that they were tasked with, which is broader than delivering water to consumers and includes stewardship of the capacity. A pure profit motive for a monopoly resource can often descend into looking for ways to extract maximal margins that are in the long run wildly detrimental both to customers and to society as a whole.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> With a profit motive, the utility is at least incentivised to deliver the service so that they can get paid. No they are not! In Britain rail companies were bailed out during Covid. Railways that had zero passengers reported profits and paid dividends! > Look at what is happening with South Africa's power utility South african society has various issues that are not applicable in UK/france/etc. Same goes for Russia. If suddenly French government does the kind fo shit Russian government does, half of Paris will be on fire before you can spell Baguette