2 ms·
I mean yeah? If we think that declining fertility rates is a serious problem, but there are dozens of equally plausible explanations, why would we prioritize yo
by gruez 3y ago
I mean yeah? If we think that declining fertility rates is a serious problem, but there are dozens of equally plausible explanations, why would we prioritize your pet cause (ie. PFAS) above all others? How does it going to work when everyone says that their pet cause is responsible for 50% (or whatever significant fraction) of the fertility decline?
Note, this doesn't necessarily mean that we should do nothing about PFAS. We just have to be honest about the potential impacts. In other words, instead of gesturing that PFAS is the primary cause for fertility decline in the past few decades (like the linked scientific american article), you admit that the impact is unclear/low, but we should still work to remove it just in case.
- ethanbond 3y ago> why would we prioritize your pet cause (ie. PFAS) above all others? Because it's the best available theory and even if it's wrong we're eliminating known toxins from our environment? What other theories have an established mechanism of action and established population-scale exposure? That's why this one should be prioritized above others (at least any that I'm aware of?). Which other theory has these? Another reason: if any portion of decline is due to these, the damage builds across generations. If this is any problem at all, it will grow to a big problem. We’re talking about future generations not just getting poisoned during their lifetimes, but being born poisoned, too. This is either not a problem at all or it should be extremely high priority, and I think the former position is completely non-viable at this point.