2 ms·
> in 30 or 60 years we may see the overall quality of life dwindle as the population stagnates or begins to decline Already happening. Even in developing count
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
> in 30 or 60 years we may see the overall quality of life dwindle as the population stagnates or begins to decline
Already happening. Even in developing countries. Less productive young people in the work force, more unproductive old people depending on social security and whatnot. Everything's gonna be fine until the money runs out. Gigantic economic disaster in the making.
There is no nation without natalism.
> This doesn't bode well for the US if it means its population could soon become similar to that of Japan's
It will. As will every other country if nothing is done to heavily incentivize motherhood and family formation.
When I say this people usually downvote me to oblivion for some reason. Maybe they think I'm making this up. Well, I'm not. They should read what actual japanese government officials have been saying about this. They use the word "extinction".
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoLet me explain then. Automation, increased productivity continue to rise at least as fast. Not clear we won't be fine simply because of that. And No we do not have to chase the Malthusian Catastrophe to 'win'. We can do it other ways. Quelling consumerism. Reigning in capitalism. Sensibly designing cities. The Japanese talk only of extinction of the pure Japan, which is on the face of it a racist policy. Not a real strong point in the argument. Japan will persist, with a normal mix of people from around the world creating a new culture that they want. Not something frozen in time that the octogenarians of Japan worship and cling onto.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> The Japanese talk only of extinction of the pure Japan > Japan will persist > with a normal mix of people from around the world > creating a new culture So what you're saying is the actual japanese people will go extinct and all the immigrants who actually have children will replace them and create a new japanese culture. And you see nothing wrong with that at all.
- Veraticus 3y agoWhy would there be anything wrong with it? This is the way cultures and people have changed since time immemorial.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> This is the way cultures and people have changed since time immemorial. Yeah, because some empire came and killed your people off and conquered your lands and enslaved your survivors and erased your culture so they could replace it their own. Not because people wiped themselves off the map because they wouldn't have children.
- Veraticus 3y agoCultures are and always have been constantly shifting and changing; conquest is one method of that happening, as you point out, but is far from the only one. Immigration, emigration, catastrophe, technological progress, climate change... all result in the movement of people and the shifting of national and cultural boundaries. No culture is "erased" as a result of this. Even if Japan fails to have children, Japanese culture and the Japanese nation will continue. It will look different, certainly. But there's nothing magical or better about the way things used to be simply because they used to be that way. Change is inevitable, and more than that, it is good.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> Even if Japan fails to have children, Japanese culture and the Japanese nation will continue. No. Nations are a collection of people with shared ethnicity, land, culture, language, history. If the japanese people disappear, the nation will also disappear. It's not going to magically continue just because the country of Japan is still there. Can't have a nation without its people.
- Veraticus 3y agoNo. Nations are lines drawn on a map. The people inside need have nothing in common other than geographic proximity. Japan will exist as long as people live there and call it Japan. It has nothing to do with ethnicity, land, culture, or history.