4 ms·
The elephant in the corner of the room of course is that the ancient Athenians quite deliberately didn't have a universal franchise. Property-owning tax-paying
by gaius 15y ago
The elephant in the corner of the room of course is that the ancient Athenians quite deliberately didn't have a universal franchise. Property-owning tax-paying full citizens who fulfilled their military obligations voted, because they were the ones that would pay for, implement and generally be responsible for whatever was voted for.
- tlholaday 15y agoAnd the property they owned included slaves, whose votes the owners did not want to count.
- rmc 15y agoThis was the dominant form of voting in most democracies until about 100 years ago. E.g. in the UK, only men who owned property could vote (can't let the common man vote!). This didn't always produce a good democracy.
- gaius 15y agoAlexis de Tocqueville: "A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the majority discovers it can vote itself largess out of the public treasury. After that, the majority always votes for the candidate promising the most benefits with the result the democracy collapses because of the loose fiscal policy ensuing, always to be followed by a dictatorship, then a monarchy." This is the one crucial defence of a restricted franchise - if the only people voting are the ones paying, they are much more resistant to this kind of corruption.
- swalsh 15y agoHis book is free on Amazon Prime by the way! http://www.amazon.com/Democracy-America-1-ebook/dp/B000JQUY7E/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1330972523&sr=8-3 http://www.amazon.com/Democracy-America-1-ebook/dp/B000JQUY7...
- javert 15y agoThis didn't always produce a good democracy. Really? I think the British Empire was a high point in world history (for both the British and their colonies). So I don't see how your point is supported. That said, I think a constitutional republic is the right solution, not democracy.
- MetaMan 15y ago"high point in world history" hahahaha - for who ? Look how many conflicts today have their roots in the decisions and actions of the British Empire. Seriously, yes, there were some side benefits eventually for the colonies but the cost was great and continues in many parts of the world. I resent that ignorant statement.
- javert 15y agoLook how many conflicts today have their roots in the decisions and actions of the British Empire Specifically, how they broke things up when they left. In general, wherever they left, things fell apart somewhat. I have talked to several people who believe their country took a turn for the worse when the British left.
- MetaMan 15y agoThe standard operating procedure of the British Empire was "divide and conquer". In order to rule a minority was usually put in a privileged position. It should be no surprise to anyone that when the British left things often become a mess as the minority tries to hold onto power and those previously excluded fight to gain power.
- javert 15y agoBut I would guarantee you that in every single case, the standard of living of the people improved substantially in the medium and long term under British rule.
- 15y ago
- larrydag 15y agoMost U.S. states adopted this form of voting power near when the U.S. was founded. Some states even allowed freed slaves that were property owners to vote.
- brudgers 15y agoThe property owning ancient Athenians also condemned Socrates to death for raising questions in regards to the status quo.