3 ms·
This isn't really the trolley problem, because the trolley problem is meant to illustrate that most of us seem to consider allowing something to happen to be le
by lolinder 3y ago
This isn't really the trolley problem, because the trolley problem is meant to illustrate that most of us seem to consider allowing something to happen to be less unethical than causing something to happen.
This version says "you must push one of two buttons and pick which person/people die". You are an active participant either way, which means most people just fall back into pure utilitarianism, which is boring.
The real trolley problem says "you have the option to flip a switch and send the trolley towards one person, but if you do nothing then it will hit X people". You either passively allow X people to die or actively cause one person's death. Utilitarianism would say that the choice is obvious, but many people choose to do nothing. That choice is interesting, and illustrates something about our psychology that this simplified version can't get at.