4 ms·
Main cause: Government-backed student loans. While it is technically the student paying, in reality the money is going (indirectly) from the federal reserve t
by londons_explore 3y ago
Main cause: Government-backed student loans.
While it is technically the student paying, in reality the money is going (indirectly) from the federal reserve to the universities.
Everyone loves free government money...
The fact the student may never pay off those loans (and hence the government foots the bill) is the cherry on top.
- drew-y 3y agoGot a source for that claim?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoCommon sense? Government (taxpayers) underwrite unlimited amounts to uninformed buyers paying informed sellers. I am a seller (college boss), and I can boost my own income, and I know I have no competitive pressure to keep prices down, so why not increase the college budget and spending, hence justifying tuition increases.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoBecause it is not 'free'. It puts students in debt. You are boosting your income by exploiting students through usury. Lets say there is no government, then where was the 'competitive' pressure? How does government loans take away competition? Did they close schools to eliminate the competition?
- lr4444lr 3y agoGood faith reading is that he means its risk free to the school, because they get paid up front even if the student doesn't graduate, much less earn enough to pay back his loan.
- drew-y 3y agoCommon sense is often wrong. I haven't found any reliable source yet that even mentions the availability government loans as being a driving factor. Based on the limited research I've done over the last few minutes, the main drivers appear to be: 1. A large increase in demand for College. I could imagine this may be, in part, due to more accessible student loans. But it appears that many factors have come into play, and the main one is the perception that you cannot get a liveable wage in this country without a college degree. 2. Less funding from state governments 3. Increased spending in administration and student services unrelated to education. Here are the sources I've read through so far. https://www.bankrate.com/loans/student-loans/why-is-college-expensive/ https://www.bankrate.com/loans/student-loans/why-is-college-... https://manhattan.institute/article/a-new-approach-for-curbing-college-tuition-inflation#notes https://manhattan.institute/article/a-new-approach-for-curbi...
- pixl97 3y ago3 is a side effect, not a primary effect. In 1 you're talking about a self-reinforcing effect. "I have to put on makeup to look pretty because everyone puts on makeup to look pretty". When everyone believes it, it becomes true.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Based on the limited research I've done over the last few minutes, the main drivers appear to be: All your drivers cannot cause a price increase if an 18 to 25 year old cannot get unlimited funding from a lender to make a stupid decision.
- mrguyorama 3y agoCommon sense is horseshit. You know what was common sense in the 1600s? A gentleman is clean, so he doesn't need to wash his hands between cutting open a corpse and delivering a baby, and oh gee why do so many women get awful infections after childbirth? Common sense is the rallying cry of people who cannot backup their claim by other means.
- ye-olde-sysrq 3y agoGoogling it provides a quick-answer box that states this claim and provides a source: https://www.google.com/search?q=what+percent+of+student+loans+are+government+backed https://www.google.com/search?q=what+percent+of+student+loan... 92% Federal student loans make up the vast majority of American education debt—about 92% of all outstanding student loans is federal debt. The federal student loan portfolio currently totals more than $1.6 trillion, owed by about 43 million borrowers. I think it's then pretty fair game for a forum comment to then suggest there's a causal relationship between "an entity that can print the currency that denominates the debt is backing the debt" and "this drives the price of the thing up due to easier access to funding for it".
- drew-y 3y agoNo, it doesn't. That quick-answer doesn't even mention rising tuition costs. It's only tangentially related. The existence of government backed student loans does not in itself prove they are the main cause of increased tuition. To prove that claim, you'd need to actually demonstrate some sort of causal relationship and have data to back it up For example, you could make the argument that: 1. Demand is the primary cause of tuition increases 2. Government backed student loans are the primary cause for the increase in demand I believe that 1 is almost certainly the main cause of tuition cost increases. What I haven't seen any evidence for is 2. If it's true, show me the evidence. I'm open to it. From what this article states and the research I've done, the main driver of demand is not cheap government loans. It's the labor market. The best jobs in this country require a college degree. That is what is probably driving demand, the desire to earn a liveable wage. Not the fact that you can get a cheap loan.
- __loam 3y agoThe article this post was about?
- drew-y 3y agoThe article does not support this claim. The claim: > Main cause: Government-backed student loans. I've read the article. It discusses student loans and how they've skyrocketed, but never makes the claim that their availability is the cause. Instead, it argues a change in America's "labor profile" is to blame for the rise in demand (which, in turn, leads to higher tuition): > Rising enrollment is also associated with a changing US labor profile; for example, manufacturing jobs were eclipsed by “business and professional services” jobs as well as healthcare, education, and retail jobs. Going further, the author suggests we need to forgive/cancel the student loans: > These loans should be forgiven/cancelled To me, this implies the author does not believe federal student loans are to blame.
- londons_explore 3y agoI believe this is no accident. The government wants a world class education system and leading research. They could just give money direct to universities - but then it's hard to ensure they're getting good value for money. But by giving it to students to in turn give to universities they get better value for money. One day someone has to pay for that - and the students paying it back via loan repayments isn't awfully different to citizens paying it back via taxes. But with the student route everyone is more invested in getting good value for money. And non-university users (who tend to be the poorest) don't end up paying. Win win.
- scinerio 3y agoA world-class education system where you can leave the $200k in debt and never exceed $100k in income. We're at a point where going into college for non-STEM degree can (and likely will be) one of the biggest mistakes of your life.
- londons_explore 3y agoBut if the government paid for it, you would never see the $200k in debt. But you'd still be in debt - it would just be government debt. And as a citizen, your government's debt is still kinda your problem.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoIf it is 'free', then why are students in debt and liable for it? (and don't confuse the issue with current debt relief bill. The current bill has not been in effect since 1983, it is trying to give relief for this situation, not causing it).
- scinerio 3y agoIt's free for universities who can rest easy knowing that if students don't pay then it doesn't affect them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAh, free in the sense that the University got its money and can now ignore any consequences? It is NOT free to the student who is definitely affected. They are in debt and now crippled. But the university got it's money. If you want to blame the government. Why is it the governments fault that Universities are now behaving like scammers and charging more for less and leaving the 'customer' stuck. ---- Lets say I go to a used car salesman, and they want to cheat me. Lets say (before 1983) I would pay 2000$ for the car, but I'm scammed and out 2000$. I lost 2000$ Lets say figuratively now it is (2020), and I can't afford the car, so a rich uncle co-signs, and give me 30,000$. I still get cheated, but now I'm out more money, AND now I'm in debt to my uncle (who lets say wants some 'payment' I feel uncomfortable performing). The used car salesman is a cheat either way, for lesser money or more money, and either way they got my money. And I'm in debt and blowing my uncle until it is paid off. In the end, I (the student) am stuck. Is it my uncles fault? Is it the crooked salesman? Maybe my uncle didn't know the salesman was a cheat either (but like a bank, does want something in return)? Should I know the salesman was a cheat? Maybe I'm young and just starting out in life and not sure about the warning signs? Should we allow the young and in-experienced to be exploited?
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
- dpierce9 3y agoI will say it again: Private high school costs have also gone up astronomically and there are no federal loans for them. [0] https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-private-school https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-private-school
- stri8ed 3y agoWhat is the rate of increase, and how does it compare to CPI inflation?
- dpierce9 3y agoThere is a chart at the bottom. Costs doubled over twenty years since 1999, directly comparable to the college rate over the same period and well above inflation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 3y agoThis said nothing about the number of seats in private schools versus public ones. If there are very few then we should expect private costs to increase dramatically as public costs increase. Not every student gets public loans, some students come from wealthy families that have other means of financing. If public is $100k, then these families would still likely choose the $120k private school for better outcomes. There is no reason for private to stay cheap.
- kristopolous 3y ago[flagged]
- 0xParlay 3y ago> It's not economics, analysis, reason or anything like that - it's pure orthodoxy and blind dogmatism. It would be rich if the data in the article in no way supported your rant.