3 ms·
Somewhat off topic, and somewhat related: I don't think there actually is such a particle as a graviton. General relativity says that you can't tell the diffe
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
Somewhat off topic, and somewhat related: I don't think there actually is such a particle as a graviton.
General relativity says that you can't tell the difference between being unaccelerated, and being in free fall. But in one case you have no gravitons coming in, and in the other you have gravitons. I can change whether gravitons are there or not by a (general) relativistic transformation.
But that's not possible. Either the gravitons are there, or they aren't. There's not two sets of reality of what particles exist for two different coordinate systems.
Therefore gravitons don't exist. The bending of spacetime is what's really going on, and there is no quantum version of the gravitational field. (Except possibly that the bending of spacetime could be quantized, but that's not what we mean by a graviton.)
I am very open to being shown to be wrong here. Can anyone do so?
- 317070 3y ago> There's not two sets of reality of what particles exist for two different coordinate systems. Look up Unruh radiation for an example of such particles. Gravitons wouldn't be the first. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect
- LatteLazy 3y agoIn relatively gravity is not a force like Electromagneticism etc. Instead, space time is curved and as a result the object itself is travelling in a straight, in accelerated line and only looks like it is accelerating to an observer outside of the curved space. So relativity has no gravitons and instead curves space. In quantum physics the opposite is true: space is flat, and gravity is like other forces, the result of particle exchange. This is one way that the two systems are incompatible. Again, happy to be corrected...
- eigenspace 3y agoThis is incorrect. A classical limit of the graviton picture fully reproduces general relativity. The incompatibility lies in the non-renormalizability of people's attempts and quantization of the Einstein Hilbert action, meaning that all the quantum loop corrections have unfixed coupling constants which can't be derived from the classical theory (unlike things like electromagnetism).
- light_hue_1 3y agoThe question of how can the Equivalence Principle work in the presence of gravitons comes up surprisingly often! You will enjoy this discussion https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/589074/why-can-t-gravitons-distinguish-gravity-and-inertial-acceleration https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/589074/why-can-t... They go over several reasons why gravitons don't break the equivalence principle. In particular the answer about virtual particles is very important.
- eigenspace 3y ago> But that's not possible. Either the gravitons are there, or they aren't. There's not two sets of reality of what particles exist for two different coordinate systems. No, this is completely false. Particle number is coordinate system and frame dependent. Quantum particles aren't little billiard balls bouncing around, and it's really best to not think of them as 'particles' at all. They're just a calculational tool to describe excitations in quantum fields.
- noslenwerdna 3y agoCan you provide an example of a Lorentz boost that changes the number of particles?
- eigenspace 3y agoIt's pretty general. Just draw the worldlines for some particles bouncing off eachother, and then perform a Lorentz boost, which means choosing a new tilted spatial surface to intersect the worldlines. If you perform a boost, then the spatial surface intersect fewer or more worldlines, and worldlines which were for particles in one frame can become antiparticles in another. Consider an electron absorbing a photon at spacetime point x, and then emitting a photon at spacetime point y, where (y0 - x0) > 0. An observer in another lorenzt boosted frame would then say that they see in their boosted coordinated system (x' and y' with rapidity v), that (y'0 - x'0) = cosh(v)(y0 - x0) - sinh(v) (y1 - x1) For large enough v, then you can have y'0 < x'0, so the observer in the boosted frame would see the events in a different order. One observer sees a negatively charged electron moving from x to y, and the other observer sees a positively charged positron moving from y to x.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoIf the events in frame 1 are causally connected, then to see the events in frame 2 in reverse order takes a boost of velocity greater than c, which is not a valid boost. Sure, you can do all kinds of things with a boost like that. It's not physically realizable, though. Can you show me an actual experiment to the contrary?
- thechao 3y ago> General relativity says that you can't tell the difference between being unaccelerated, and being in free fall. Just to be clear, GR only says this for a very specific case, and a very specific observer. In fact, one of the easier exercises when first learning how to work with metrics is to show how to measure the difference.
- snowwrestler 3y agoSaying one theory must be wrong because the other must be right is begging the question. Where general relativity and quantum theory disagree, we don’t know which one is correct (or maybe neither is). Highlighting a point of disagreement between the two doesn’t, by itself, resolve the disagreement.
- scrubs 3y ago"General relativity says that you can't tell the difference between being unaccelerated, and being in free fall" I think this is a misunderstanding. Special relativity says you can't tell the difference between free fall (in a gravity well) and inertial acceleration with the example of a guy in an elevator typical here. Both cases have acceleration. My question: does an accelerating elevator due to motors and pulleys curve spacetime too?