3 ms·
> If the US respected the law Whose law? The US is a sovereign nation. US law explicitly allows them to snoop on foreign entities/persons/data. GDPR doesn't
by tristor 3y ago
> If the US respected the law
Whose law?
The US is a sovereign nation. US law explicitly allows them to snoop on foreign entities/persons/data.
GDPR doesn't have jurisdiction outside the EU.
I wish it were otherwise, but it is not. The EU isn't a world government, it's a regional government/alliance, somewhat analogous to the US. The US often manipulates other nations to agreeing to pass laws that align to their policy goals globally, but ultimately it's a decision of sovereign nations to pass laws. I don't think the EU wants to call into question the entire concept of sovereignty in a policy conflict with the US, since the US is the a hegemony and one of only two global superpowers (and arguably the only one).
- tmikaeld 3y agoBad choice of word, maybe agreement? In essence, as long as the Cloud Act exist and is enforced, I fail to see how US <-> EU data transfers can ever be GDPR compliant.
- tankenmate 3y agoThe GDPR applies to EU citizens regardless of where they are, and if the EU courts can apply fines (for example the company has a presence in the EU) then the court will probably fine the company.