6 ms·
Instagram Threads hits 100M users, becoming the fastest growing app
- moneywoes 3y agoWhat do we thinking retention will be like?
- withinboredom 3y agoStill US-only, I think.
- agd 3y agoNot correct, it's live in many countries (including the UK). The main area it hasn't launched is the EU due to legal concerns.
- huhtenberg 3y agoLegal concerns = It can't work without violating rudimentary privacy and tracking restrictions mandated by the EU.
- true_religion 3y agoIt doesn’t work in China for the same reason.
- ElectronBadger 3y agoI *highly* doubt that the reasons are the same for EU and China.
- withinboredom 3y agoI suspect the reasons are the same (privacy), but the motivation behind them to be quite different…
- thih9 3y agoNote that while it's officially banned, there are ways to access it and people are doing that. > Threads, launched on Wednesday evening US time, already ranked fourth among free social media apps in Apple’s iOS store in China > The app has gained traction even though users based in China must use virtual private networks to access the platform. Source: https://www.scmp.com/tech/big-tech/article/3226962/metas-twitter-rival-threads-tops-chinas-app-store-despite-great-firewall-censorship https://www.scmp.com/tech/big-tech/article/3226962/metas-twi...
- dsr_ 3y agoI'm assuming retention and participation numbers will be gamed.
- Eumenes 3y agoComparable to the Metaverse I'm thinking
- tough 3y agoAre they new users, or just IG users that login with their previous account into a new feature that lives in a separate app? GG number crunchers at meta I guess
- jeromegv 3y agoWell they still got that amount of people to download a new app, but yes, they are all IG users.
- mliker 3y agoThese are new or existing IG users. Either way, the user must download the app and go through a full onboarding flow to increment the count, which is how publications are tracking. The count is public for anyone to see.
- tough 3y agoI wonder how many of those are already bots tho lmao https://github.com/junhoyeo/threads-api https://github.com/junhoyeo/threads-api
- tough 3y agoYes, if you launch a new product and promote it heavily to an already captive audience, you can easily convert a lot of them to try the new product. Hardly new science here?
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoI bet Facebook Messenger grew faster.
- callamdelaney 3y agoTheir definition of 'signups' is very, very liberal.
- Kiro 3y agoHow so? I thought they had to download a new app, which for me is a huge barrier.
- RankingMember 3y agoyeah, I won't be joining until (if?) they open up the web app
- callamdelaney 3y agoWho on the planet needs to sign up for yet another social network? Plus now you need to have the teenage girl app to use it? It's a no from me dawg.
- optimalsolver 3y ago>Who on the planet needs to sign up for yet another social network? The people flooding out of Twitter: https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-rapid-rise-of-threads-appears-to-be-hurting-twitter-f557ba6e https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-rapid-rise-of-threads-appea...
- callamdelaney 3y ago'people are leaving twitter, trust me bro' - wsj
- optimalsolver 3y agoCloudFare has the data: https://www.threads.net/t/Cue0QR5LAV2/ https://www.threads.net/t/Cue0QR5LAV2/
- 3y ago
- importantnuance 3y ago[flagged]
- pixxel 3y agoYet another piece that totally avoids mentioning Facebook. Almost as if instructed…
- MikusR 3y agoOr WhatsApp or Quest, or Messenger. Must be some kind of huge conspiracy.
- WrtCdEvrydy 3y agoYou mean Instagram Threads, a subset of Instagram, purchased by Meta which was formerly know as "The Social Network That Shall Not Be Named"?
- bravura 3y agoIs it possible to use threads without connecting it to my existing Instagram account? I know that Zuckerberg said: "You have one identity. The days of you having a different image for your work friends or co-workers and for the other people you know are probably coming to an end pretty quickly. Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity." But I use Facebook + Twitter to talk mainly about work, science, tech, etc. I use Instagram for a completely different audience and post about music, art, etc. Does my threads account link to my Instagram account?
- FemmeAndroid 3y agoI think the easiest solution is to create a second Instagram account. That’s what I did. Instagram supports having multiple accounts signed into the app at once, so it’s not much of a pain once you’ve set it up. I had an issue where I opened threads before realizing I wanted to create a new Instagram account for it. I had to hard quit the threads app, create the new account on Instagram, sign in with it, then re-launch threads.
- bravura 3y agoYou need a second phone number to do that correct? As I recall, there are very strict protections and verifications in place by big social networks to prevent bot and spam accounts. Is this actually allowed by the TOS? For individuals, not brands, to have multiple accounts?
- FemmeAndroid 3y agoIt is very much supported. Top left, click on your name, 'Add account', and go from there. I think in the backend the accounts might be associated for security/abuse purposes, but Instagram actively wants you to be able to have more than one account. I'd imagine it would be a lot harder to avoid being 'thirsty on main' without these features. Just checked, and signed up with a random second account. They add the phone number from the previous account you were on by default, and mention copying your other non-public information over from the previous account you were signed in to.
- tinyhouse 3y agoI downloaded but haven't used yet cause all my followers are still on Twitter. I was curious how the app looks like and can tell that they weren't joking when they said it's a Twitter clone. I'm a bit surprised that a company like Meta has no shame in copying another product one to one. (Not sure how this phrase sounds in English)
- RankingMember 3y agoI never found Twitter's interface to be good to begin with, so it's always struck me as a little silly that apps like Mastodon and now Threads are copying it whole-cloth. (your use of "one-to-one" is perfect English by the way)
- isykt 3y agoIf we’re counting people using a feature of an account they already have as “growing,” WeChat has surely done this faster many times, and many times over. They regularly release apps. Or iMessage, which was released in 2011 when there were 115m iPhone users. That year, iMessage gained 115m users, since it was bundled with the phone. The metric is kind of contrived.
- mliker 3y agoThe "feature" happens to be a full app that you must consciously download. You must then go through the onboarding flow before finally the number of users is incremented. That's just like downloading any other app. These are not trivial numbers.
- mliker 3y agoTo add to that, these numbers don't include EU folks, who cannot download the app and onboard.
- Hamuko 3y ago>That's just like downloading any other app. Any other app that is being actively promoted inside an app you've already downloaded and using. https://twitter.com/GUMBastard/status/1677386533312012305 https://twitter.com/GUMBastard/status/1677386533312012305
- selykg 3y ago
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoI joined Threads and followed the same people I follow on Instagram. Real slick signup process. What's everyone talking about? Mostly a combination of Hello, World! type posts, and "why is Threads showing me random celebrity crap? I don't care what kind of weird tree Paris Hilton just saw." For that reason, I remain sceptical of retention. Besides, my audience on Instagram, i.e., not programmers, is so different from the audience I had when I had Twitter.
- BoxFour 3y agoI must admit, I find threads quite enjoyable. Perhaps it is the novelty factor, but I find myself establishing contact with individuals (and even them contacting each other for the first time) whom I rarely engage with otherwise, as they tend to frequent different social platforms (Twitter vs IG vs TikTok vs Snap). Typically my social networking engagement is almost strictly HN, so witnessing everyone I know engaged in vibrant interactions has proven to be a fascinating experience after a prolonged period of relative quietness for myself.
- ceshm 3y agoThis has also been my experience, and as you I suspect it might be related to the novelty factor. Let's see if engagement remains the same.
- 65 3y agoI hate the Threads user experience. You're force fed content from brands, divisive political figures, meme pages, and influencers, and given no way to discover accounts you actually want to follow. At least on Twitter it's easier to find accounts to follow. I get it's an MVP, but the current format of being designed as a totalitarian app that controls all the content you see makes it unusable to me.
- shrikant 3y agoYeah. Please, FFS, I just want a chronological feed of people I follow -- not something that's been growth-hacked to death from the very beginning and stuffs my face with a ladbible and a memeczar and random brands with their Gen Z social media interns posting hot takes :'(
- twelve40 3y agoYup, totally repulsed by that, too. I wish they just had a paid option to remove all that crap, but noo, it's mandatory you get fed that daily. So i end up going there once a month or so, just to check on my remote friends still on FB/IG.
- MAGZine 3y agoThe enshittification also seems to be growing the fastest too. The first day or two was great. It was only content from the immediate network, or things they liked or reposted. Now? So much low-effort content. Like "memezar" posting "lost my girl but won the argument". Or other accounts like "wasted" (ironic) and others. Perhaps threads is trying to Speedrun the Twitter algorithm, and next week we'll see more outragey political and news based items. You know, for engagement.
- invalidusernam3 3y agoImpressive considering it is unavailable in the EU
- DebtDeflation 3y agoMaybe I'm becoming a Luddite as I get older, but it seems to me we've passed peak social media. All these apps are just a spin on the same core set of features. I can friend/follow someone, I can post text/image/video, I can comment on someone's text/image/video, I can like/share someone's text/image/video, and others can do all of the same to me. On the flipside, all my data gets hoovered up and sold to people who want to show me ads they think I will click.
- barrysteve 3y agoCore features are the same, but the pretense is different. What else matters now? It will take a long while for excellence to win out again.
- Zigurd 3y agoThere is not much wrong with doing a competent job of consolidating a trailing-edge product category. Especially when you have the best ad tech and largest audience.
- thejohnconway 3y agoI agree with your sentiment in general, but Threads isn’t intended to be new, it’s supposed to be Twitter, competently run.
- tmikaeld 3y agoThreads feels like a rehash of the same old social media features, with the added frustration of being force-fed content from brands and influencers, rather than a feed of people I actually _want_ to follow. And while the initial surge in signups is impressive, it's largely due to Meta's captive billion people audience and the novelty factor. The real test will be retention, particularly as the user experience leaves much to be desired. Also, the idea of having one identity across all platforms feels restrictive and dismissive of the different facets of living. Having separate identities for different aspects of life isn't a "lack of integrity" as zuck calls it, it's a necessity. I fear we're headed towards a future where we're all bland versions of ourselves, carefully crafting simplistic, unified public identity that's easy for marketers to target while limiting the freedom of expression.
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> Threads feels like a rehash of the same old social media features Because it is... It's very clearly just a knock off twitter for people that are fed up with Musks' shenanigans.
- taylodl 3y agoHere's my experience - the only social media site that has ever censored me is Facebook. Whenever I say Trump should get whatever is coming to him through the process of law I always get put in FB jail and told I "violated community standards on hate speech" - then they go on to define their standards on hate speech: - Attacking people due to sexual orientation - Attacking people due to their religious affiliation - Attacking people due to the gender identity - Attacking people due to their disabilities - Attacking people due to their political affiliation - Attacking people due to their race I have done none of these things. I make it clear Trump should have the long arm of the law applied to him for his crimes against the United States and if he in fact committed treason, which should be determined thru due process in court, then he should be hanged. That's not hate speech - that's how I believe anybody committing treason should be treated. Oh, and where do I make these comments on Facebook? On Trump's sponsored adds where he's whining about Joe Biden and the DOJ "politicizing" justice and attacking poor, innocent Donald - and hey, can you send me some money to pay the legal bills for these unjust attacks? I think my comments are warranted on these kinds of sponsored adds. So no, I won't be using Threads. Twitter is a far sight better for allowing freedom of expression, regardless of what Elon Musk's detractors may say. Zuckerberg has shown time and again he's the much worse option to Musk.
- rambojohnson 3y agoand it's 90% influencers / brand advocates. meaningless noise. 80% of the time I'm muting accounts. also, 100% of those "new users" are instagram accounts that have simply enabled the integration...