4 ms·
PLEASE DO NOT READ THAT ARTICLE - it is bad for you and your business. SEO is a bullshit industry. this means that 80% of everything that is written about SEO
by franze 15y ago
PLEASE DO NOT READ THAT ARTICLE - it is bad for you and your business.
SEO is a bullshit industry. this means that 80% of everything that is written about SEO actually reduces your knowledge of SEO, that article is in no way different.
just pick a few examples:
> A web crawler has to crawl your site (and every other site on the web)
> Indexes all the pages ..
> Organizes the indexed collection and stores ...
this one misses on of the most important steps of the google site processing pipe: Discovery is the process of discovering URLs to crawl. It is fueled by the sitemap.xml and crawling.
PageRank - is not - "another important part of authority" - pagerank is thoughtcancer. don't ever say that word, don't ever think that word. see my TC article here http://techcrunch.com/2010/07/07/startups-linking-to-your-competition-will-help-you-no-really/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/07/07/startups-linking-to-your-co...
>Ensure pages render without JavaScript enabled
sadly google parses and to some degree renders JS ... badly. this tip is good, but leads to the false conclusion that google does not parse/render/"see" JS.
> you should also pay attention to how you construct links and anchor text to internal pages on your site.
internal link anchor text is mostly irrelevant.
>your own internal links use relevant keywords in the anchor text.
it's also some of the worst things, as the impact in minimal to not measurable.
>So if you load a bunch of text dynamically with Ajax, or JavaScript, create a non-JavaScript version that will show the same information.
outdated, google now even does onload-triggered POST requests if necessary. js is still bad, but the story above is only half the story.
>Put them in the URL (and even better if your domain name has your keywords)
oh god, not again. these are the SEO URL rules
#### landingpage url rules
all URLs on an a webproperty must be according to these rules
listed in priority!
1. unique (1 URL == 1 resource, 1 resource == 1 URL)
2. permanent (they do not change, no dependencies)
3. manageable (1 logic per site section, no complicated exceptions)
4. easily scalable logic
5. short
6. with a targeted keyword phrase
further down she says something about 404s and it sounds like they are bad. 404 are great. when pages are gone, they are gone - 404 or 410. if the move then 301. but do not redirect gone pages to friendly 200 pages. keep your site simple and your redirects rules as well.
>Additionally you want as many links to contain appropriate alt text.
links don't have alt text, images have alt text. in an image is linked, that alt text substitutes the anchor text.
>But SEO isn’t just about building a great site that is crawlable and has the right content – it is also about converting users.
no, that is the job of the product, onpage marketing, conversion optimization. SEO is really just about getting - targeted - visitors. (she has clearly read too much SEOmoz)
>the most defensible SEO strategy is links,
no, it's not. that is just something that SEO agencies tell you to sell you their services and useless tools.
disclaimer: i work as an SEO - i hate SEOs. my biggest success is 62 M visitors a month. i don't read SEO blogs.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoYou just took five minutes of my time telling me how bad something was and not one second offering an alternative. For all the bad things your critique basically just boiled down to "not it's not" without offering proof or links. Do you see something wrong with this picture? As a reader all I've got from your comment is angry guy doesn't like SEO and thinks all SEO blogging is for shit. I apologize for being so blunt, but this is not a very useful comment. Perhaps the goal here is to establish how much you know, but even then it really fails to convince the reader. It'd been great if it had been a bit more constructive. Obviously you believe you know what you're talking about.
- toumhi 15y agoI second that. Pointing out what a good SEO strategy is and how it opposes the points described in the article would have been helpful. If somebody interested in improving their SEO skills should not read well-known SEO blogs then what does the OP suggest? I personally follow SEOMOz and a few established SEO and link building blogs, but would be interested in hearing other suggestions.
- franze 15y agoi'm telling you the same thing i told the CEO of an international publishing house: read a book instead! Search Engine Marketing Incorporated http://www.amazon.com/Search-Engine-Marketing-Inc-Companys/dp/0136068685/ref=dp_ob_title_bk http://www.amazon.com/Search-Engine-Marketing-Inc-Companys/d... [not an affiliate link] sadly, nobody ever does.
- paulhauggis 15y agoYou're telling us to read a 4 year old book on technology that changes on a monthly basis? Lots of SEO involves guess work. Google changes its algorithm constantly. That's the reason nobody reads books on SEO. It's the same for web development.
- 15y ago