3 ms·
I think the onus should be on Sarah Silverman to prove which inputs were hers and which outputs leveraged those inputs. I think she should pay all of the court
by echelon 3y ago
I think the onus should be on Sarah Silverman to prove which inputs were hers and which outputs leveraged those inputs.
I think she should pay all of the court costs if she fails to do so.
- tjmc 3y agoWell yeah - that's how the legal system works assuming it gets all the way to court. In reality, Meta and OpenAIs lawyers will do a risk evaluation against the strength of the claim and if there's any merit at all there will be a quiet settlement.
- batguano 3y agoIANAL, but my understanding is that in the United States, a civil defendant who prevails is not usually entitled to have their legal fees paid by the plaintiff. [0] https://porterlaw.com/obtaining-attorney-fees-in-litigation-as-a-california-construction-contractor-or-subcontractor/#:~:text=The%20general%20rule%20in%20California%20is%20that%20each%20party%20pays,throughout%20most%20of%20the%20country https://porterlaw.com/obtaining-attorney-fees-in-litigation-...
- preseinger 3y agohow could someone "prove" which inputs and outputs of a large ML model leveraged any specific data?
- echelon 3y agoThat's her and her legal team's homework assignment.
- preseinger 3y agono, it isn't it's an unsatisfiable requirement, and unnecessary to substantiate the legal claims it's dumb to talk about
- echelon 3y ago> it's an unsatisfiable requirement, There's a wealth of primary literature describing means to probe models for the training data. There's also discovery and a whole host of other processes to answer this question. The plaintiff that filed the lawsuit should prove what they allege. > unnecessary to substantiate the legal claims Why? What if the model has absolutely zero of her data in it? Should she even be allowed to bring this case to court? > it's dumb to talk about Absolutely not! It's central to the entire case. Even if her data is in the model, there's still a question of whether or not she should be compensated. I'd argue no for the same reason that babies that grow up watching Disney don't owe their entire intellectual output to the company.