This does at least correctly name the main character, but I think it's otherwise hallucinated. The plot of the story is that Jonathan Rugg is a Quaker who work

This does at least correctly name the main character, but I think it's otherwise hallucinated. The plot of the story is that Jonathan Rugg is a Quaker who works as a clerk in Philadelphia. His boss sends him on a trip to Jamaica (credit for mentioning the Caribbean!). After arriving, he meets a woman who asks him to guard for her an ivory ball, and says that there are three men after her who want to steal it. By coincidence, he runs into the first man, they talk, he shows him the ball, and the man pulls a knife. In the struggle, the man is accidentally stabbed. Another man arrives, and sees the scene. Jonathan tries to explain, and shows him the orb. The man pulls a gun, and in the struggle is accidentally shot. A third man arrives, same story, they go down to the dock to dispose of the bodies and the man tries to steal the orb. In the struggle he is killed by when a plank of the dock collapses. Jonathan returns to the woman and says he has to return the orb to her because it's brought too much trouble. She says the men who died were the three after her, and reveals that the orb is actually a container, holding the ruby. She offers to give him the ruby and to marry him. He refuses, saying that he is already engaged back in Philadelphia, and doesn't want anything more to do with the ruby. He returns to Philadelphia and gets married, swearing off any more adventures. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Howard_Pyle%27s_Book_of_Pirates/Chapter_8 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Howard_Pyle%27s_Book_of_Pirat...