6 ms·
Peptide analyses reveal female leadership in Copper Age Iberia (C. 2900–2650 BC)
- DoreenMichele 3y agoThey are testing teeth to determine biological sex of prehistoric remains which have previously proven difficult to clearly identify. This bit is the part most interesting to me: Second, early 3rd millennium Iberian societies do not display the traits indicative of highly stratified, class-like or state societies identified elsewhere in Bronze Age or Iron Age Europe. As the Valencina record shows, leadership systems in the Iberian Copper Age were at best unstable and financed by a wealth economy rather than a staple economy59. ‘The Ivory Lady’ appears to have drawn her influence, prestige, or power neither from birth, nor from the control of agricultural produce, but from her personal charisma and her achievements. TLDR: It seems that a society with powerful women may correlate to different social and power structures than male-dominated cultures.
- _ktx2 3y agoIf that TLDR is your own then you may be interested in this book: https://www.nebraskapress.unl.edu/nebraska/9781496205117/ https://www.nebraskapress.unl.edu/nebraska/9781496205117/
- DoreenMichele 3y agoYeah, it's my own. My eye tends to go to social dynamics. Thank you for the book recommendation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zgluck 3y agoMy suggestion: read the actual text and while doing so, note the weaselwords. Here's my list: implies, suggests, fair to assume, suggested, were interpreted as How does this get published in Nature [Open Access]?
- paddw 3y agoWhat are you expecting for any article about ~5000 years ago
- zgluck 3y agoSomething less certain than the headline
- softwaredoug 3y agoWhen I got my history degree I was told that qualifiers were often GOOD as they don’t overpromise our degree of certainty. Grammarly has a good article on qualifier usage and over usage https://www.grammarly.com/blog/qualifiers/#:~:text=%E2%80%8B%E2%80%8BA%20qualifier%20is,of%20writing%20sound%20lazily%20constructed https://www.grammarly.com/blog/qualifiers/#:~:text=%E2%80%8B....
- throwaway72762 3y agoIf a paper doesn't have that many caveats it won't get published. Scientists, good ones anyway, are rarely able to speak definitively about almost anything, especially something as hard to study as this.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoExcept for global warming, vaccinations, lab leaks, phrenology, psychiatry, bloodletting, safety of thalidomide, perhaps?
- wokearch 3y ago[dead]
- dec0dedab0de 3y agoI tend to assume that anyone who doesnt qualify their statements with so called weaselwords is lying to me. But I definitely think that discussing anything from so long ago better use this type of language, because there is no way to be sure
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- huitzitziltzin 3y agoSome of the inferential steps in this article are… “heroic” might be a polite way to put it. “Furthermore, the fact that none of the infant burials found in Valencina have grave goods suggests that, among the communities that lived in or frequented this site, social status was not ascribed by birth (and therefore no significant inheritance of wealth occurred), contrary to what would happen later in the Early Bronze Age)32. Therefore, it is fair to assume that the individual inhumed in structure 10.049 gained a prominent social position through merit and personal achievement and did not ‘inherit’ it by birth.” I mean… on the basis of the tombs that have been found you want to infer that? Sorry but there’s ten other stories that fit the available evidence. This interpretation really stretches credulity beyond the breaking point.
- zgluck 3y agoThe entire article (please actually read it before interacting here) is built upon multiple staggered leaps of faith and ends up collapsing. The authors should study high-school level probability theory.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cataphract 3y agoYeah, I could even buy the first part, I don't know archaeology and can't say which inferences about the society you can make based on the existence or absence of grave goods in that era. But it's one thing to characterize the society of the time based on the totality of evidence, it's another to ascribe "merit and personal achievement" to one specific person.
- jojobas 3y ago-Excavations near Bristol revealed copper wires, indicating their use of wired telegraph. -Excavations near Nowherabad revealed nothing, indicating their use of wireless telegraph.
- 3y ago
- Slava_Propanei 3y agoHow do you know that the skeletons identify as fenable
- rdevsrex 3y agoThis is an interesting find, but it's not surprising to find a woman of prominence in that era. Before agriculture really took off, hunter gatherers were pretty egalitarian and a lot of kinship systems were matrilineal. Also, I think that it's more likely that this person was a shaman, than a chief, but that's just a speculation on my part.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThis is the copper age and the late neolithic, so agricultural, not hunter-gatherer era.
- midoridensha 3y agoHumans were a lot better before they invented agriculture.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoThey may well have been matrilineal because prior to IVF etc, you could be certain who the mother was but not the father. It has its good points but shouldn't be assumed to be an expression of high ideals. Most likely, quality of life went up for most people thanks to agriculture. Before that, war, abortion, exposing unwanted infants and insisting some people just leave the tribe and not come back were some of the means humans used to keep population levels sustainable and avert mass starvation in hunter-gatherer societies.
- midoridensha 3y ago>They may well have been matrilineal because prior to IVF etc, you could be certain who the mother was but not the father. According to research I've read, pre-agricultural societies, and even more recent tribal hunter-gatherer societies, frequently had no concept of monogamy at all, and didn't worry about who people's fathers were, because children were raised by tribes/villages at large. Monogamy was an invention that came about with agriculture, because that's when the concepts of land ownership and inheritance came about. >Most likely, quality of life went up for most people thanks to agriculture. Actually, no: human height dropped about 30cm with the introduction of agriculture, because nutrition in an agriculture-based society is much worse than in a hunter-gatherer society. It took many millennia (as in, only very recently) for human height to get back to pre-agricultural levels.
- klysm 3y agoQuestionable epistemology here for nature
- soligern 3y agoThis article is an extreme reach full of improbable assumptions. Anything to make it seem like women has some level of parity I guess. At least their hearts are in the right place but it erodes trust over time.