4 ms·
Original author here. My six-year-old rant still mostly applies (there've been some improvements to tag editing, and there's now in-article search for the Andr
by dredmorbius 3y ago
Original author here.
My six-year-old rant still mostly applies (there've been some improvements to tag editing, and there's now in-article search for the Android app), but Pocket still massively underdelivers, increasingly as one relies on it more.
Most recently, I found I had to revert to a six-month-old version of the app in order to have both paginated navigation and to be able to open the "web view" in app ... which is where occasionally useful things such as tag editors live. Thread here: <https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/110680672833582286 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/110680672833582286>
That said ... I've largely given up on Pocket delivering what I would like to see, and if I can steer discussion here, I'd really like to know what Android-specific and/or e-ink tablet tools people have for managing large article repositories on device.
I'm familiar with Zotero and Calibre, though both are desktop only, as well as Wallabag.
Mendelay is a no-op given Elsevere's ownership.
Anything I don't yet know of?
My long-standing dream is to create KFC, Krell Functional Context, a document management tool that would include webfs and docfs components, inspired somewhat by Plan9OS and its P9.
More on that in another "dreddit" rant: <https://web.archive.org/web/20200918215041/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/6bgowu/what_if_the_web_was_filesystemaccessible/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200918215041/https://old.reddi...>
- canadaduane 3y agoWas this a case of enshittification, per Cory Doctorow, or something else? [1] https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/ https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/
- dredmorbius 3y agoGiven that enshittification is a power play by a dominant monopoly, and Pocket really doesn't seem to have any such power, I'd argu that it's not that. Plain old incompetence and/or failure to articulate product-market fit seems far more likely. Specifically as regards Pocket, there seem to be both a constant war against those using the tool, and/or who are inflicted with it (it's packaged/bundled with Firefox these days), neither of which do much to engender good relations. There's also what I see as a terribly misguided goal of trying to be a content recommendation engine, when I suspect that the problem most of us face isn't not having sufficient gobs of content shoveled at our faces, but in trying to make sense of that which we have acquired. Tools such as workflows, date-based tagging, multi-tag search (being able to search, say "german" and "comedy", rather than "german" and "comedy" separately --- basic AND logic), date-stamping articles (when they were input, when they were read, when they were highlighted / forwarded), the ability to compile article lists to send via email, metadata exports, the ability to directly edit metadata (automated tools often get the basics wrong: title, author, date, etc.). Export of articles to a durable document format --- saving a single article to a PDF or ePub document, or multiple documents, etc., etc. I've discussed most of this at length with Pocket's support for years, or rather, had some years ago and largely gave up the effort when there seemed to be no discernible movement in directions I'd encouraged.
- ausbin 3y ago> I'm familiar with Zotero and Calibre, though both are desktop only There's a third-party Zotero client for Android named "Zoo for Zotero" that has worked well for me: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mickstarify.zooforzotero https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mickstarif.... However, I usually use it to read academic papers on my phone that I have already added to my library using my computer. I tried adding something new to my Zotero library on my phone as I was typing this comment, and sadly the interface seems a little clumsy: I can add papers to a collection but not a subcollection
- vvladymyrov 3y agoI’m using Pocket for reading articles on eink in spare time - I use Kobo Forma - it has 8” screen and is lightweight and has a decent battery life (unlike newer Kobo Sage). Not all articles are saved though. I used to do a trick with Remarkable 2/kobo - exporting webpage on iPhone into Dropbox as pdf - resulting pdf is formatted for a small screen For pdfs and web reading I use Boox Onyx Air - with 10.3” screen and full android browsing experience… But I need to sit and hold larger screens with two arms, while with Kobo Forma I can hold in one hand while layout down. Boox recently released Page - 7.8” lightweight android ereader, but I’m not sure that android device would hold battery as good as Kobo Forma.
- dredmorbius 3y agoOnyx BOOX Max Lumi here, 13'3 inches of 2200x1650 pixel, 220 dpi, 16 greyscale goodness. The device is quite frankly fantastic, despite a somewhat anemic (for my purposes) onboard storage of 64 GB (doubled in the follow-in Max Lumi 2). (I'm perennially well above 90% utilised, though a good chunk of that are podcasts.) I've written about that at length in other HN comments, search should turn those up for anyone interested. Yes, it's huge, but it means (almost) never having to pan-and-zoom within scientific or scanned-in magazine articles. Smaller devices can work, though 8" is probably the smallest I'd consider for serious reading. My experience with Onyx is that when used just for e-books the battery life is excellent. Once you start web surfing or playing podcasts, battery starts getting chewed pretty quickly, though a charge still lasts most of a day. My preferred web browser (Einkbro) easily consumes 10x the power of Neoreader (Onyx's ebook reader software). I'm increasingly finding the Web just ... generally less interesting (though of course it is compelling to a painful degree), and have amassed a large library of books and articles mostly in PDF, ePub, DVJU, and a smattering of other formats. Organising those usefully is the 2nd 90% of my content-management frustration. Writing is the 3rd 90%. Oddly enough, Termux provides a number of tools there that I find useful, including a healthy chunk of the libpoppler PDF tools, though that really needs an external keyboard (which I have, it's still somewhat awkward to use). What I really wish Pocket would do is: - Render Web-based articles in a fixed-layout, paginated, comfortably-margined (sides AND top/bottom) layout, with e-book-reader style touch-based page turns. (Whatever your favourite ebook reader does, that's what I'm talking about, Neoreader is quite good, I've also used FBReader and Pocketbook, and looked at the Koboreader software a bit.) - Let me tag, highlight, and annotate those to my heart's content. - Let me SEARCH the damned archive, by metadata and full text. - Let me edit metadata where automated tools (or poor original creation) have fouled things up. - Let me export lists of references with relevant metadata: title, author, URL, dates, etc. I've adopted a number of practices to make up for holes in Pocket's offerings. - I started tagging items with a "filed: <datespec>" tag a couple of years ago. I'd really like for that to be a built-in feature, and for search by time-period to be A Thing: past day / week / month / year, as well as spans. With my tags and an exported dataset I can at least build my own tools to do that. - I've got a handful of projects that I'll tag a piece with if it pertains to that, so "project: <projectname>" Given the 25-character tag limitation, "proj:" would probably be a better prefix. - Similar concepts for "task: <stuff>" and "error: <description>", where tasks are specific to-do type things (e.g., "hn" for "post to Hacker News"), or "print" for make a hardcopy printout. "share: <email-or-name>" could also be reminders to ping somebody with an article. - "BOTI" is "best of the interval", the notion being that this is an exceptionally good item. More recently I've been relying on Einkbro's "save as ePub" feature which enables saving multiple articles, over time, to a single document. So you can build up a book of articles. (One thing I've realised from doing that is just how much reading I put on my plate. A small sampling of articles from the current year already runs to ~400 pages as an ePub.) - I've got a notation for indicating my assessed article quality, on a scale of 0 to (for now) 5, with higher being better. 0 indicates content that makes you dumber (usually archived as examples of bogosity or negative propaganda). 1 merely establishes a basic fact, 2 gives some detail, 3 is a high-quality article, 4 exemplary article or a good book, 5 effectively establishes a new field or is otherwise a definitive reference (say: Shannon's articles on information theory). I try very hard to not over-rate content, and one of my projects is downrating a bunch of stuff I'd initially ranked too high.
- diarrhea 3y agoZotero has an iOS app that is rather good.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAs I've commented before, given that many e-book readers are Android based, the lack of an Android client is ... curious. iOS of course lacks an e-ink based device.
- bmulholland 3y agoLooks like no one has mentioned Readwise Reader (https://readwise.io/read https://readwise.io/read), which I use and is a great experience.
- projektfu 3y ago(ReadCube) Papers, but I honestly haven't tried it since like Papers 1, so can't speak to how it is these days.