5 ms·
Schizophrenia Breakthrough: The Hidden Culprits Are Somatic Genetic Mutations
- matthewfcarlson 3y agoTIL about somatic mutations. Many classes teach that your DNA is a sort of constant across your body with localized mutations. It’s odd to think of it as a fork of a fork of a fork (and so on). That half my cells could have a chance and half don’t is odd to me. It makes me much more suspicious of 23andme genetic testing results
- astrange 3y ago23AndMe is fine because it's conservative about what it reports, but genetics papers are generally very non-credible (as in, they haven't heard about the Credibility Revolution). They constantly use tools that can only show correlation like GWAS and then just pretend it's causation. And yes, because of somatic mutations their favorite tool "twin studies" is not reliable. (On the other hand, I'm not sure we want them doing intervention studies that could show causation, it seems kinda unethical.)
- rogerkirkness 3y agoTo be more specific, 23andMe shows your full exome which is where proteins are encoded in your DNA. Sort of like how having the entire codebase doesn't necessarily tell you what's going on in production with memory corruption, behavior on certain hardware, cache misses, etc. the analogy works well.
- Terr_ 3y agoIn a way, the most impressive somatic genetic mutation occurs when mammalian red blood cells simply yeet everything in order to hold more hemoglobin. I think it kind of puts things in perspective, about how much scope for change is possible for cell-lines which are destined for a narrow non-gamete purposes.
- specialist 3y agoNoob question: what's the diff between somatic genetic mutation and epigenetics? This OC's working hypothesis is that somatic copy-number variation is the culprit. Is copy-number variation a form of epigenetics? Is there a clear cut boundary between what is a transcription error and gene expression feedback loop? Way out of my depth here. I have a personal interest in schizophrenia and only seek to better understand what's what. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copy_number_variation#Molecular_mechanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copy_number_variation#Molecula...
- vintermann 3y agoThe cookie consent forms on that page are a lesson in dark patterns.
- aatd86 3y agoGreat catch. Ooff!
- aatd86 3y agoBut how to diagnose schizophrenia especially if this is triggered by substance ingestion (caffeine, cannabis, other psychoactives) . If it has a biochemical origin, how is it gene related? Weird. And also what advantage does it provide in evolutionary terms? Or is their claim is that it is some form of epigeneticism? Strange, strange, strange. The genetic argument is always a bit dubious.
- mistrial9 3y agodegenerative conditions are not exactly "triggered" ; for a very bad analogy, consider the difference between a leaky auto tire and one that has a sudden puncture. Human beings have evolved to maintain biological function for survival; partial functionality, imperfect execution, less-than-wonderful judgement can go on for years and years; nutrition and sleep, emotional context, and yes, drugs use and abuse, contribute to wear and tear.
- movpasd 3y agoDisclaimer: not a psychiatrist. A common model for mental illness is the "stress-vulnerability" model. The idea is that people have more or less vulnerability to mental illness, and that this vulnerability is tested by external stressors.