4 ms·
I've seen a line of reasoning here (hn) that threads has stolen mindshare and impetus, and bluesky will be seen as "reactive" rather than innovative respective
by ggm 3y ago
I've seen a line of reasoning here (hn) that threads has stolen mindshare and impetus, and bluesky will be seen as "reactive" rather than innovative respective of planned intent and outcome.
Basically, marketing not technology will win. That, and instant signing on by uplift of the existing meta user base.
Google+ lost out on drive and will to live. It was a nice experience. Nice guys, came second in the race. They lost impetus, and they lost c* backing. Bluesky at least won't have that problem, it's the core product not a nice-to-have.
- paulgb 3y agoAs I see it there are really two twitters: consumption twitter and conversation twitter. Consumption twitter is where people go to follow celebrities, athletes, news publications, brands, etc. Most twitter users don’t post, they belong to consumption twitter. Then there’s conversation twitter. It’s smaller but it was there from the beginning, even before the celebrities showed up in force. It seems to me that Threads will capture the consumption twitter market. I’m far from convinced that Threads will capture the conversation twitter market. So far, Bluesky feels to me the most like early twitter, community-wise.
- threeseed 3y ago> I’m far from convinced that Threads will capture the conversation twitter It really depends on what you're discussing and the tone you're looking for. Threads is already discouraging the type of brawling, political discussions you get on Twitter. But it's amazing if you're wanting to talk about entertainment, photography, sports etc as the tone is more fun and positive courtesy of all of the Instagram people and the assertive moderation.
- whyenot 3y ago> marketing not technology will win As it should. No matter how amazing the technology may be, a social network that almost nobody uses is a dud. IMO every day that Bsky stays in private beta it is losing more potential users. Marketing is more important than tech. Look at Threads, there is nothing particularly revolutionary about it’s tech, but in large part thanks to marketing and seeding the platform with well known users, it appears to be off to a great start.
- jitl 3y agoG+ felt pretty dead and lifeless when I joined during beta. It’s major innovation was “circles” - tools to share to a smaller percentage of your contacts. Bluesky does not feel dead or lifeless, it’s much more lively than Mastodon because it isn’t fragmented by default, and the user-designed feed algorithms are a cool way to discover new conversations.
- unmole 3y agoFor a brief period around 2012/2013, G+ was awesome. It was the best way of following people who shared your interests. If Facebook was for keeping in touch with people you went to highschool with, G+ was for keeping in touch with people you wished you went to highschool with.