4 ms·
Thought-Terminating Cliché
- mandmandam 3y agoIt is what it is. That's life. Don't overthink it. ... Seems to me that these clichés grew rapidly in the last couple decades. The fact that people just accept without challenge that Threads will de-platform anything "political" [0] is an outcome of this kind of thinking, imo. People would have been a lot more cynical about such a move (from Mark "they trust me - dumb fucks" Zuckerberg) fifteen years ago. 0 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36636486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36636486
- pphysch 3y agoMore examples: "whataboutism", "you sound like <bad guy>", "this is <bad thing> propaganda" It's definitely gotten worse in recent decades. Oratory and intellectual debate are increasingly rare in our society since the Cold War. Political bipolarity eviscerated the American/Western intellect.
- mandmandam 3y agoIndeed - there seems to be a concerted attack on nuance, and even thinking. Great people like Stallman, Tesla, Feynman, Chomsky, Assange and Snowden, etc, are smeared and dismissed due to unrelated, out of context, twisted, false selections of views. Tribalism is fed and magnified, saying the 'wrong' (no matter if true) thing gets you dismissed as a conspiracy theorist / tankie / Trumpist / how many other "thought-ending insults". No questions, no time for looking at evidence, just thrown in the 'other' bucket. Biden asked Twitter to censor true information that went against the preferred narrative, and the so-called left wing collectively decided "there's no there there", it's a "nothing-burger". More clichés. And the 'other' sides thought-ending clichés are so barmy that it's impolite to even describe them accurately; and it physically hurts to even try. And it does go back to that "bipolarity", which acts very like a monopole on certain big issues like oil, war, equality, censorship, and people not in the tribe. I don't think we can blame it all on social media or human nature either. In too many cases, you can point to someone shadowy putting their finger on the levers of power. Murdoch, Turner, Zuck, etc; they all have a lot more in common with each other than with us.
- robocat 3y ago> And it does go back to that "bipolarity" It happens in New Zealand too, and we don’t have bipartisan politics
- Given_47 3y agoInteresting. So I’d imagine it’s less predetermined but people still end up taking a certain side and from there all the same toxicity appears
- mandmandam 3y agoThat is a very fair point - this is quite possibly an issue right across "the West" (which can include NZ in this case). I've noticed it in Ireland, in France, in Germany. Even the Scandos seem not to be immune. I'll have to think about it some more. I will say this though - America is at the vanguard of anti-intellectualism, and has been for quite some time. Mark Twain commented on it frequently, for example. And even so, the last couple decades have seen the dismissal of deep / nuanced thinking grow far worse, even as "bipartisanship" also rapidly got bad enough to bring us a lot closer to civil war than I expected in the 90s. One last point - it's weird that this would happen even as everyone gets nerdier. People all use computers, watch LOTR and Harry Potter, cosplaying and conventions are all normalized... It's not what I'd have expected.
- HKH2 3y agoI could be wrong, but Americans seem very interested in keeping up appearances. People have freedom of speech, but do they really try to say what they want to say and risk looking like a bumbling idiot? Pioneering in one's mind and creating nuance is not easy and cannot be prepackaged for the masses, so how can it compete in a materialistic society?
- pphysch 3y agoPolarization is everywhere (in AUS/NZ mainly due to being part of Anglosphere yet proximal to China), but in America it is on a totally different level than NZ. I occasionally will see nuanced, heterodox comments from AUS/NZ politicians that would not be tolerated in Washington.
- beaned 3y agoSome of these just seem like things people say when they don't want to dig in to a conversation for convenience, or don't have an interesting reply. The article sort of lays them out as having a type of sideways intention, but often these ones are more benign. I think there are probably better examples.
- jawns 3y ago> An example of the cliché in use provided by Chaz Bufe is "the admonition given to Catholic schoolchildren to recite the Hail Mary or rosary to ward off 'impure thoughts'. The use of repetitive chanting by the Hare Krishnas serves the same thought-stopping purpose." Neither of these examples have much relevance to thought-terminating cliches, whose purpose is to "stop an argument from proceeding further," because neither of these examples involves an argument. Rather, they both have a meditative purpose, intended not to end thought but to focus it on something. In the case of Catholics reciting the rosary, the intention is to focus their thoughts on the mysteries of their faith. In the case of Hare Krishnas chanting the maha-mantra, it is intended to achieve self-realization by connecting with Krishna. But whatever. I'm entitled to my opinion, so let's just agree to disagree.
- _Microft 3y ago> let's just agree to disagree That‘s one, I‘d say.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThat's interesting. "Agree to disagree" means "you aren't going to persuade me, I'm not going to persuade you, conversation over." That's one kind of debate-ending cliche. There are others that are "you're wrong, conversation over". Calling someone or something "X-ist" is often that. I guess both of those can serve as thought-ending cliches, because now I don't have to think any further about what you say. But in terms of what they do to the conversation, they are not equivalent.
- vacuity 3y agoIn this case, parent laid out their thoughts already and didn't make it a "I'm going to pit my value/belief against yours and not bother to elaborate because I'm right" situation, which is where I find something like "let's agree to disagree" banal. I think it can make sense if one expounds on one's value and leaves off with that phrase because there's a legitimate impasse (which may entail more discussion to discover). Parent was more making an observation of the examples not fitting the definition, so there's not really a value judgement.
- wayeq 3y ago"Well, I don't know about all that."
- carrozo 3y agoAt the end of the day, it is what it is, and it ain’t what it ain’t.
- renewiltord 3y agoI think on HN that would be "this is not Reddit" or like any other forum "correlation isn't causation".
- robocat 3y agoThat is selection bias.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago"Sir, this is a Wendy's."
- danw1979 3y ago“You’re wrong, and you’re a grotesquely ugly freak”.
- l0b0 3y agoSometimes the medium itself is thought-terminating, like IRC and all its offspring (including Matrix): - It's basically impossible to have more than one productive discussion going at any time. - There's no threading (or threading is a mostly half-baked ignored niche feature, like in Matrix), so 90% of answers are followed by everybody else just guessing which comment they answered. - You need to seize the moment to keep the other participants engaged and to avoid confusing readers (see above), so quick answers rather than thoughtful ones are more likely to get a follow-up.
- jakeogh 3y ago"Conspiracy theory" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21343067 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21343067
- dragonwriter 3y ago“Thought-terminating cliché” is most commonly, ironically, used as a thought-terminating cliché regarding a meta-level critique, dismissively labelling it without engaging with it.