4 ms·
You say that as if these events are unfortunate accidents instead of lack of technical leadership. I’ve met quite a few “unlucky” people in my life and what ne
by hinkley 3y ago
You say that as if these events are unfortunate accidents instead of lack of technical leadership.
I’ve met quite a few “unlucky” people in my life and what nearly all of them had in common was the inability to connect their actions and inactions to consequences. They were blindsided by predictable outcomes over, and over, and over again. Eventually the people who could actually help you get tired of your drama and move on, and then you’re left in an echo chamber where your narrative makes sense.
I’ve spent a lot of time on this job thinking about the thoughts and plans of the people who have left. If our vertical were more compelling I believe we could make a better product with the people who have left than with the people who stayed. Even considering the lack of depth in domain knowledge. There’s a lot of things that don’t change because they were the right thing to do ten years ago. That’s an explanation for how we arrived here, not a reason to stay.
- Silhouette 3y agoYou say that as if these events are unfortunate accidents instead of lack of technical leadership. Sometimes they are. I've seen several applications that were successful for many years but eventually had to be rewritten because some vital dependency was no longer viable. In web development we had an early generation of web apps that used plugins like Flash or Java to do things. Fast forward five years and those plugins have been brutally killed off by the browser developers. However other web technologies have become viable alternatives for some of those things. That's a big rewrite. Some programming languages have had big jumps that weren't entirely compatible. Python 2 to Python 3 is an obvious example that took years but eventually resulted in not only Python 2 no longer being supported but some libraries never being updated to support Python 3 and others being created to provide similar functionality. In this case many of the direct code changes could be automated but you can't automate swapping out each obsolete library for a replacement with a similar purpose but a different API. And maybe you wouldn't want to because in the 5 or 10 years since you built the last version new ideas have come along and you're better off adopting them instead since you have to make a big change anyway.
- goto11 3y agoBrowsers discontinuing Flash support is indeed a good reason for porting an app to a different platform. But this is also a very different scenario than the grandparent example, where the cost of maintenance due to bad code quality is supposed to justify a ground-up rewrite. In the Flash example there is a clear business case for porting, even though it is understood the porting will expensive. The fallacy is believing a ground-up rewrite will lead to more maintainable code. This is just developers deluding themselves. There is no reason to think a ground-up rewrite of existing working code will lead to better and more maintainable code.
- Silhouette 3y agoThere is no reason to think a ground-up rewrite of existing working code will lead to better and more maintainable code. As with almost every argument in this area that depends very much on context. A substantial rewrite might be an opportunity to use better tools and improved techniques that have been developed since the original was written. In some cases that could represent a huge improvement in things we actually care about like developer productivity and the quality and performance of the product. Importantly this doesn't imply anything was done wrong or any bad decisions were made by the developers of the original product or the people who have maintained it so far. It's just that we work in a fast-moving industry and sometimes even a few years can see some big improvements in what the available technologies can do. A development team starting with a relatively clean slate can take into account all the knowledge and feedback received over the lifetime of the existing system. Maybe it was too expensive to make use of those insights while evolving the original system but a new version can take advantage of them. Again that can represent big gains in areas that we care about. It's often observed that a big rewrite risks losing a lot of small improvements and fixes that have accumulated over the lifetime of the existing system and of course that's true. However it's also true that a big rewrite can avoid a lot of existing design problems or get rid of long-standing bugs that no-one was ever going to get around to fixing. I've seen big rewrites that didn't end well. But I've also seen big rewrites that were done for sensible reasons and had very positive outcomes. And I've also seen things that should have been rewritten but weren't and instead became a drag on everything. There is no universal rule here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]