7 ms·
I have lost all trust in GitHub, and not because of the vulnerability, but because of their response. With their suspension of hamakov's account and deceptive b
by epistasis 15y ago
I have lost all trust in GitHub, and not because of the vulnerability, but because of their response. With their suspension of hamakov's account and deceptive blog post about the extent of the hole, GitHub has guaranteed that they won't be the first to know about the next vulnerability (and there's always another).
I've downgraded my paid account to a free account, and won't keep any non-public data on GitHub in the future. I had a similar response with my (non-paid) DropBox account. I guess I didn't rationally evaluate cloud resources, and have trusted far too many people.
- codesuela 15y ago^ this, I just moved my prive repo to bitbucket hoping that Atlassian would have handled this issue better. At least they seem to have more experience looking at their long history in software. I will also look into setting up my own git(orious) server.
- DeusExMachina 15y agoI personally know some people that work for Atlassian and they are awesome. Moreover, they really do care for their customers. I have no experience using Bitbucket, but given the people I know I would definitely trust them.
- phzbOx 15y agoI have to agree that suspending the account was dumb as if he wanted to be malicious, he'd have created dummy accounts and would have committed malicious code to popular projects. But then, going so far to say losing all trust in github.. there was a bug, it's fixed and they suspended the "attacker". I wonder what will happen in the following days with script kiddies trying to "hack" all rails website. In fact, isn't the overloading of parameters something as old as the earth that security experts would check first as a vulnerability?
- chrisacky 15y agoThis is a perfect summary and exactly the sentiments that I couldn't express in the article. I've quoted you with attribution if you are okay with that?
- epistasis 15y agoOf course. I can't imagine that I'm the only person leaving GitHub because of this.
- dangrossman 15y agoI'm just going to latch on to this comment to make mention of a GitHub alternative for private repositories: http://repositoryhosting.com/ http://repositoryhosting.com/ I've been a happy customer for a while now, and have seen them recommended on HN many times. You get unlimited repositories with unlimited users for less than the cost of GitHub's cheapest 5 repo plan. My open source code is on GH, but it's all also pushed to RH, along with all my private code.
- zalew 15y agoYou should check out http://bitbucket.org http://bitbucket.org
- dangrossman 15y agoI prefer to pay someone to host the private repos. No free tier means every user is treated like a paying customer, and every user's data is considered valuable. It also means that as long as the pricing is sane, the company isn't going to shut its doors for lack of revenue. Before RH I was paying Springloops. It's $6/month to take care of my most important assets. That doesn't even buy a meal at McDonalds anymore; it's worth it.
- zalew 15y ago> as long as the pricing is sane, the company isn't going to shut its doors for lack of revenue. BitBucket is owned by Atlassian for 2 years now and they don't look like they're about to go out of business ($60mil revenue in 2011, 400employees, worldwide offices). When they bought it, it was them who set private repos to unlimited (when @jespern was running it alone, it was set to 5), so I believe they know what they're doing and that it fits their business model. Over 5 collaborators need a paid plan and that's just how they set up the pricing scheme. As far as I can see as an active user and lurking through their blog and bugtracker, BB is actively developped, so I assume you don't have to worry about them running out of business, looks like it's a valuable asset in Atlassian's software portfolio (at least valuable enough to work on it).
- 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JackDanger 15y agoThey suspended the account, they didn't cancel it. On a Sunday morning when you're fixing a security hole and you know who penetrated it you suspend that person's account. On Monday morning you figure out what to do with them.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yalogin 15y agoIf the vulnerability is that serious should they have not taken the site down instead?
- esrauch 15y agoIs there no middle ground?
- somestuff 15y ago"On a Sunday morning when you're fixing a security hole and you know who penetrated it you suspend that person's account." Haha what. Do you maintain any sites? Tell us what ones. I want to warn all of your users that the admin is someone who will disable an account of someone who committed to master on a project that is not theirs and feel he has accomplished something.
- tar 15y agoThis is probably the perfect time to switch to http://bitbucket.org/ http://bitbucket.org/ . They offer free unlimited public and private repositories for both Git and Mercurial. However, the free private repositories are limited to five collaborators.
- MartinMond 15y agoYeah, I think we'll migrate all our private stuff to http://gitlabhq.com/ http://gitlabhq.com/ The way GitHub reacted (blocking @homakov) is just wrong and destroyed all my confidence in them. Even more so when it was pointed out that @zedshaw crashed GitHub and didn't get blocked. http://sheddingbikes.com/posts/1306816425.html http://sheddingbikes.com/posts/1306816425.html Edit: Given that they have now stated that suspending @homakov was only temporary I no longer bear any ill will towards them. I'm still disturbed by their security practices though. I expected better by the github guys and I don't like what this implies about the rest of their App. (And yes I am using attr_accessible and not attr_protected since its inception) Edit 2: See here http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3664839 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3664839 My worst fear that GitHub is using unsafe mass assignment everywhere was NOT confirmed.
- tylermenezes 15y agoCoincidentally, the incident with Zed was also fueled by the ruby guys being dicks. He just happens to be a higher-profile personality.
- eugenejen 15y agoIt is rails guys, not ruby guys. I am still wondering why people can't distinguish two different communities. You don't mistake python and django or php and kohana or java and strut, right?
- kamaal 15y agoIt doesn't work that way. Rails is a major reason for the kind of push Ruby got. There was a time when CGI and Perl were synonymous. You won't believe how many people have a similar opinion about JQuery and Javascript these days. A few days back I wanted to use a object oriented language for a big project. Generally I straight away go and use Perl for all my experiments. But since this time I wanted Java programmers to be working with my project later I thought let me use Python as its more syntactically closer to Java. When I started coding, my manager peeked over my shoulder and asked if it was Python in which I was coding I replied yes. He immediately asked me to stop writing in it, as he thinks writing in 2.x is waste of time as it is going to go away, 3.x is not yet having all the libraries. And writing 2.x will force a huge rewrite effort later. I tried and reasoned enough to convince other wise. But alas, it didn't fly. That is how it works with pointy haired managers. They read something some where and then hold strong opinions about a particular technology. As programmers we can try and educate people in forums like these. But managers don't read these forums. They are likely to read magazines from IBM and Oracle, where XML's are glorified and eclipse is presented as the biggest productivity booster ever. Unless we get a forum on such magazines, we won't be able to make much difference.
- technoweenie 15y agoWe suspended it after fixing the bug to make sure he didn't retain access to something he shouldn't. We rarely do this, but he wasn't upfront with everything he was doing on the site like people that disclose vulnerabilities responsibly.
- niyazpk 15y agoThe sad part is that the guy was your biggest fan: http://homakov.blogspot.in/2011/07/octocat-tattoo.html http://homakov.blogspot.in/2011/07/octocat-tattoo.html
- technoweenie 15y agoIt's a fake.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- reustle 15y agoCitation needed
- openbear 15y agoNot sure if technoweenie was trolling or not, but Homakov said on Twitter "That tattoo is kind of fake made with henna". http://twitter.com/#!/homakov/status/176476394455437312 http://twitter.com/#!/homakov/status/176476394455437312 "Thank you all,sweethearts! For support, and shit too. One more thing to clarify. That tattoo is kind of fake made with henna. eat vegetables"
- epistasis 15y agoOddly, I don't feel that GitHub is being upfront with everything that's going on here. It appears to be a very complicated story, but it was presented in an entirely different manner. I recognize that it's difficult to present a coherent story when everything is playing out in real time on the web, but the blog posts seem to have shared just the wrong amount of information.
- res0nat0r 15y agoNot to downplay the exploit at all, but for everyone raging that this occurred and are worrying about the integrity of their codebase, we are talking about an SCM for god sakes aren't we? Git is distributed and all most users would need to do who are freaking out right now about evil commits is to go back and audit your git commit history no?
- angrycoder 15y agoClearly the only secure and rational solution for all of us is to print out our source code every hour and store it in a shoebox under our beds.
- raganwald 15y agoTry to be serious. What are you gonna do, type your source back in by hand? Punch cards, paper tape, cassette recorder, pick one.
- ComputerGuru 15y agoHe was being snarky.
- tdoggette 15y agoOCR, duh.
- GFischer 15y agoYou're snarky, but that's exactly the way we used to protect source code intellectual property here in Uruguay until recently. Nowadays you can hand a CD, plus a printed manual. Printing the code is now optional. But you still have to register every version :) http://www.cuti.org.uy/registro-de-software.html http://www.cuti.org.uy/registro-de-software.html