3 ms·
This will just make app developers angry at your platform. If this is just some hack users are doing apps will increasingly use attestation to make sure you are
by charcircuit 3y ago
This will just make app developers angry at your platform. If this is just some hack users are doing apps will increasingly use attestation to make sure you are not feeding them fake data.
Apps want to be able to give users a good user experience and if they are given fake data users will get angry that the developer's app is broken and leave 1 star reviews. Denying permissions and letting apps know something is denied is much better because they can adapt their app's experience to work around it.
- firefoxd 3y agoThis doesn't make sense. If the dev asks permission that creates good experience, the user is incentivized to give real data. Example, gps is required to navigate or find near by service. The user will happily provide. But if you require gps to make a post, the user does not benefit from it. Unless they have an incentive to share their location, they do not need to give real data. Maybe the dev should give an explanation. If they receive a one star review, the developers should use it as feedback.
- charcircuit 3y ago>But if you require gps to make a post, the user does not benefit from it. This behaviour would get an app rejected from the app stores. The app stores require you justify doing things like that and they require you to gracefully degrade if a user denies a permission.
- jeroenhd 3y agoApps don't want to give users a good experience. Apps want to milk users for all the data they posses. Denying permissions remains an option, but some digital trash will refuse to work unless you give them your address book and location history. Those apps deserve to be fed fake data. Clicking the "feed fake data" button is an explicit alternative to denying permissions, it's not a replacement.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Apps want to milk users for all the data they posses. No, they don't. Please go and actually talk to app developers for their motivations. Look at the mission statements of the companies making the apps. >Those apps deserve to be fed fake data. Or you can just not use the app if the experience it offers is not something you want. >Clicking the "feed fake data" button is an explicit alternative to denying permissions, it's not a replacement. It's a worse alternative because apps can not properly handle this case unless they detect the data being fed in is fake.
- zzo38computer 3y ago> Clicking the "feed fake data" button is an explicit alternative to denying permissions, it's not a replacement. Yes, it should be a separate option. However, instead of "feed fake data", perhaps the options should be "Allow", "Deny", and "Custom"; if you select "Custom" (which you can do also when installed or in the settings menu, even when the app is not running) then the user can program their own handler of the data requests, and can also choose from a list of such programs which have already been programmed before.
- immibis 3y agoFine, then don't make an app. Your loss, not mine.
- charcircuit 3y agoIf you are building an app platform the whole point is to get as many quality apps on it as you can. Telling app developers to go pound sand and not make an app for your platform is your loss.
- immibis 3y agoSomeone else will make that app without the tracking.