3 ms·
Super cool! Yet another example showing that animals are more complex than we thought :-). > The researchers also say that the ants' movement could someday be
by palata 3y ago
Super cool! Yet another example showing that animals are more complex than we thought :-).
> The researchers also say that the ants' movement could someday be used to inform the design of autonomous swarms of robots that perform search and rescue missions in disaster areas or explore landscapes on other worlds.
Can we stop with the default "it could be useful for search and rescue in disaster areas"? That's the default "I don't see an application, let me just find an extreme case to justify my research".
There is no need to justify it: learning about ants is interesting on its own, and so is building a new robot.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThey are just putting a kind face on it. Search and rescue isn't much different from search and destroy, which is the real goal and how they will sell it to military buyers.
- mhb 3y agoReading the cynical view that the real goal of x is military/harm/etc. is also pretty tiresome.
- goodbyesf 3y agoNot the cynical view, but realistic view. Reality isn't cynical even if it is tiresome. The impetus behind most major tech - satellites, planes, nuclear technology, etc was to provide the military a better way to kill people. Of course it was sold to the public in a more positive way.
- mhb 3y agoReality? The funding, results and motivations of the parties involved are complicated enough that dismissing it with this cynical view is so overly simplistic that it's not worth mentioning. Even the notion that the military's aim is to "kill people" is ridiculous. It's aim is be able to kill people so that actually killing them isn't necessary in order to defend its own people.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> The funding, results and motivations of the parties involved are complicated enough that dismissing it with this cynical view is so overly simplistic that it's not worth mentioning. People aren't that complicated. Especially at the top. > Even the notion that the military's aim is to "kill people" is ridiculous. Ridiculous? It's the basic core function of a military. Imagine a military that couldn't kill people. Now that would be ridiculous. > It's aim is be able to kill people so that actually killing them isn't necessary in order to defend its own people. By your logic, the russian military is defending russians by killing ukrainians in ukraine? The US military was defending americans by killing iraqis in iraq? How does that logic work? I thought the military exists to spread democracy [ in oil rich countries ]?
- tough 3y agoThey where/are defending the Economic interests of the ruling classes of those countries indeed
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agohttps://youtu.be/fS5ht9ZhxtM?t=125 https://youtu.be/fS5ht9ZhxtM?t=125 (Friends: the one with GI Joe)
- mhb 3y ago[flagged]
- DropInIn 3y agoAny development, no matter how mundane, will eventually be turned to use by a military or paramilitary group somewhere at some point. From this it can actually be argued anything developed is developed to eventually be used for warfare....
- eggy 3y agoOr the converse, that the military and porn industry R&D lead to civilian products and usage like ecommerce via online credit card processing from the porn industry and GPS and jet engines to name a few from the military sector.
- palata 3y agoI don't think so. They are just trying to justify why they do that kind of research, in the fear that people won't understand "we do research in order to understand more".
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y ago>> There is no need to justify it: learning about ants is interesting on its own, and so is building a new robot. That's how research gets funded. If you look at research funding applications there is usually a question about "impact" or "benefits" etc, that you have to answer, so you basically have to explain why you should be given (usually public) money to satisfy your intellectual curiosity. Depending on the funding body you may need to have more or less obvious applications of your research (or none at all; obviously if you're in a purely theoretical field nobody expects you to propose practical applications! But then you have to explain why your research project is of interest to other purely theoretical folks). If the applications are dead obvious, then that's even better for all involved and particularly so the reviewers of the application: they don't have to think about it too much. "Ants' search patterns? Oh, I get it, search and rescue. Check!" and then go to the next part of the application that really makes the heard hurt, like "We propose to study the difference between army ants' and fire ants' antenna use for pathfinding during a storm to determine the effect of species- and group-specific communication on colony search efficiency". Yikes.
- palata 3y agoRight, yeah I guess you're right. Feels a bit sad though, but that's how it is.