3 ms·
They are the ultimate ask for forgiveness rather than permission. Copyright has been a thing for a long long time before googs developed their scanning. They we
by dylan604 3y ago
They are the ultimate ask for forgiveness rather than permission. Copyright has been a thing for a long long time before googs developed their scanning. They were well aware that it should have been an opt-in, but knew they’d never gain traction for their little project. So they bull in a China shop’d their way to a point of too far to stop them.
- philipov 3y agoThey don't even ask for forgiveness. They are "don't admit you've done anything wrong to begin with."
- remus 3y agoCopyright is to do with protecting reproduction of works, no? What google has done here is scanning the book and indexed the content, presumably so it makes it easier for users to search books for relevant material. Assuming they don't reproduce large sections of copyrighted works in their search results I don't feel like they're doing anything wrong here.
- tpxl 3y ago> Assuming they don't reproduce large sections of copyrighted works They do (or did). They showed the text around the search term, around a page or so, which made it possible to reconstruct the whole book without that much effort.
- extra88 3y agoYet the keep getting sued and keep winning in the courts, at least in the U.S. Seems like they have a pretty good grasp of how the laws work.