3 ms·
Can we reasonably assume that in the idea of "looking at the ultra rich to help solving poverty", there is fundamentally an idea that... well... it should be do
by palata 3y ago
Can we reasonably assume that in the idea of "looking at the ultra rich to help solving poverty", there is fundamentally an idea that... well... it should be done in a way that will help poverty?
Or was it that unclear that I was talking about solving poverty, with the idea that all the money that goes for ultra rich could actually be distributed better?
- lolinder 3y agoRhetoric matters, and you didn't say "looking at the ultra rich to help solve poverty", you said "prevent the ultra rich [from] get[ting] even richer". If you had said the former, I wouldn't have objected. What you actually said felt more like class warfare than a serious proposal to help poor people.
- palata 3y agoIt goes, literally, like this: > Solve poverty > How? > Maybe a first step would be to prevent the ultra rich to get even richer. If you can't understand the similarity between this and "looking at the ultra rich to help solve poverty", honestly I don't know what I can do.
- seventhtiger 3y agoYou can do us a favor and outline for us how doing that is a first step to solving poverty. Otherwise it seems like you just regurgitated a populist meme.
- palata 3y agoOk, let's say you find a way to distribute the resources evenly between everybody. Haven't you solved poverty then? Then if you want to solve inequalities, do you think it's easier to start by solving inequalities between the poor people, or is it easier to start by taking money from those who are insanely rich for no good reason?
- mcpackieh 3y agoStep 1) Murder tens of millions of people for the cause. Step 2) ???? Step 3) Equality!
- palata 3y agoI said "prevent the ultra rich from getting even richer", and you understood "murder tens of millions of people for the cause". That escalated quickly. I would be tempted to say that you completely, absolutely hallucinated the meaning of my words, but then... well English isn't my first language, so maybe that's on me.
- seventhtiger 3y agoYour first step is "take" and your second step is "figure it out". If you did figure it out, you wouldn't have to be forcefully taking. Are you assuming we already have enough resources to solve poverty? Isn't the actual issue that even with perfectly equal distribution we don't have enough resources for every body? If the pie isn't big enough, why is the communist's focus always on how to divide the pie, rather than growing the pie? Do communists have anything to add at all when it comes to increasing productivity so we can all have more? Wasn't lack of productivity exactly what killed communism? Even China didn't wake up until it opened its markets. Inequality isn't increasing because poor people are doing worse. Poor people are doing better. Poor people's conditions are improving faster than they ever have. It's true that the richest people's wealth grew even faster than that, therefore increasing inequality. But if you really care about the wellbeing of the poor, then you wouldn't distracted by inequality when the conditions are improving. You'd interrupt the most successful ever for the worst system ever, driven by jealousy, bitterness, and moral indignation.
- palata 3y agoI can't really tell you how communists think, to be honest, because I am not exactly one. It's a weird thing (in the US?) that everyone who is not libertarian is considered communist (and not any communist: mostly the kind that is "the enemy" in cold war era video games, apparently). There are many systems that would probably be considered communist in the US (at least by those of you who seem to have no clue about anything that is not libertarian) that work really well without genocides. But you'd have to open a book that is not US-centered to see that.
- oneshtein 3y agoUSSR did that. USSR collapsed. 250M of people suffered, more than 30M died. Rinse and repeat.
- oneeyedpigeon 3y agoYou would never apply this attitude to programming. "Well, I got a segfault, better never touch this C language again..."
- mcpackieh 3y ago> You would never apply this attitude to programming Really? 30 million deaths wouldn't give you pause? Therac-25 killed or injured 6 people and we still talk about that. Communism doesn't deserve another chance.
- palata 3y agoBecause you think that no non-communist system has ever killed anyone? The point of the parent is that the fact that USSR collapsed does not mean communism (or any kind of less liberal system, for that matter) is fundamentally bad. Just like getting a crash does not mean that the language is fundamentally bad. What about this one, following your reasoning: "The Nazi were producing cars, and the Nazi brought us into a world war. Therefore no one should ever produce cars again".
- mcpackieh 3y agoCommunism is bad because communists think the ends justify the means and (as you are demonstrating) shamelessly excuse tens of millions of murders (proving they've learned nothing and will do it again when given the chance.)
- oneeyedpigeon 3y agoI don't think communists "think the ends justify the means" any more than capitalists do, probably less if anything.