5 ms·
Having watched them murder Star Wars, Willow, and now Indiana Jones, this seems relatively tame.
by robertlagrant 3y ago
Having watched them murder Star Wars, Willow, and now Indiana Jones, this seems relatively tame.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAndor is quite good. But still a bit too much Disney in some scenes.
- pavelstoev 3y agoI actually very much appreciate how adult it is.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoMandelorian was good on Season1 too. It seems shows have a chance of skating by, but if they are well reviewed they’ll get Disney Fingers all over them starting in their second season. Andor was great. Give me one reason to think they won’t screw it up.
- t0bia_s 3y agoAndor was actually very nice surprise to me. Only SW show that is not just casual "go there do this". 9th episode has best space "battle" I ever saw in cinema.
- robertlagrant 3y agoHorses on a space ship? Give me Wrath of Khan in the nebula any day.
- t0bia_s 3y agoHorses?
- robertlagrant 3y agoIn space[0]. [0] https://youtu.be/2surd184-6s https://youtu.be/2surd184-6s
- robertlagrant 3y agoI agree Andor was great - I genuinely found myself on the edge of my seat once or twice watching it. But one decent TV show out of several, and no new movies in years? Terrible performance.
- jvanderbot 3y agoRogue one was excellent movie wise. Mandalorian was ok, at least season 1 was downright good. But yeah, it's no longer a guaranteed good time. But was it ever? It seems to me half of the first 6 movies stand up on their own. Then probably 1 out of the next 3 involving Ray. The side plots are now better. Any good animated entries?
- andrepd 3y agoI wonder how releasing new films (good or bad) is supposed to "murder" an existing franchise.
- mustacheemperor 3y agoIndiana Jones, as a franchise, mostly exists to present-day audiences as a series of Harrison Ford movies. Which, to sidecar a bit, seems like a shame when the point and click titles made by the Monkey Island folks were absolutely fantastic. I'd say Fate of Atlantis is a way better 4th installment than Crystal Skull. But at any rate, following up a movie generally viewed as mediocre with what's shaping up to be one of the most expensive box office failures of all time after a delay of many years seems like it could only damage any lingering value in this IP. If it's not outright "murdering" the franchise, I'd say Disney has left Indiana Jones in a much worse spot than it was 20 years ago, and not just because the original movies are 20 years older. Revisited Fate of Atlantis recently and was just reminded of the awesome rollercoaster in Disneyland, and it is kind of mystifying how this entire franchise was apparently allowed to slip away from relevance. Not just in movies - The Uncharted games are fantastic, the new Tomb Raiders sold many copies, people want swashbuckling adventures and the market's been saturated with milsims and scifi for years. The last 20 years of the franchise just look like one big missed opportunity parade.
- majormajor 3y ago20 years is a bad comparison point for "did Disney kill Indiana Jones." Disney bought Lucas just over 11 years ago. So what was the shape of the franchise at that point? After a well-received film in 1989 and a well-received but niche Fate of Atlantis video game in 1992, and a TV series for a year or so (so not a smashing success, though I remember people liking it) in 1992-1993) it went dark movies/TV-wise, and none of the followup video games amounted to too much. So the franchise wasn't in great shape or popular relevance pre-Crystal Skull, and that film certainly didn't help. It was largely disliked by audiences, and Dial of Destiny actually seems better received by audiences so far. Personally I thought it was a far better film, though not a "must see" - but how much blood is in that stone to squeeze out with an aging Harrison Ford compared to, say, Uncharted? Anyone blaming Disney for the state of Lucasfilm franchises seems to have a huge chunk of selective memory for the 2000s. (E.g. for me, I stopped paying attention to a lot of new Star Wars media for a while after Vector Prime in 1999 and the resulting story arc.)
- Hikikomori 3y agoHey now, Spielberg and Lucas fucked Indiana Jones long before Disney.