6 ms·
This seems like a nice altruistic useful thing, but (given some overly-trusting security practices we still often see) it'd still be good practice to keep some
by neilv 3y ago
This seems like a nice altruistic useful thing, but (given some overly-trusting security practices we still often see) it'd still be good practice to keep some ideas in mind...
DECREASING LEVELS OF SECURITY:
1. Running Microsoft Windows.
2. Running out-of-support Microsoft Windows.
3. Running out-of-support Microsoft Windows and having it report itself to a server of unclear provenance and security (which could be efficiently indexing such insecure machines, and possibly even exploiting vulnerabilities during this simple interaction).
4. Running out-of-support Microsoft Windows and updating its system software from a server of unclear provenance and security (which could install malware, possibly even defeating any outdated vendor signing).
SUGGESTIONS:
* If your important science/medical/industrial/etc. equipment is stuck on ancient Microsoft Windows, probably you want to keep it airgapped and treat it gingerly, while planning to upgrade to more sustainable equipment (and hopefully it doesn't fail abruptly before convenient).
* If you're playing with Microsoft Windows for personal use, that's fine, but maybe consider whether you'd prefer to spend your time and energy instead learning and creating atop an open source software platform.
* For many business and personal purposes, Debian Stable is a good OS platform, and this is one installer for it: https://cdimage.debian.org/debian-cd/current/amd64/iso-dvd/ https://cdimage.debian.org/debian-cd/current/amd64/iso-dvd/
- p0w3n3d 3y agoWhat about retro gaming?
- anthk 3y agoWINE will run tons of w9x games with assistants provided by Lutris just fine.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>* If you're playing with Microsoft Windows for personal use, that's fine, but maybe consider whether you'd prefer to spend your time and energy instead learning and creating atop an open source software platform. Open source does not address my need or desire for Windows, regardless outdatedness. Seriously, it's annoying that fReE and oPeN sOuRcE are thrown around like they will solve all the problems in the world. Spoiler alert, they don't. Especially if that problem involves a practical need that most libertarian neckbeards wouldn't care about. Yes I run Windows, and yes I happily run EOL Windows because they are required to run something reliably. And yes, I happily run unpatched Windows because updates break shit and waste my time compared to the dangers posed by hypothetical threats outside my practical threat model. Something being free or open source does not in any way fundamentally address my needs and desires. No, Wine is not a panacea (unless we're talking about the drink). No, I'm not going to waste even more time getting Linux to work just so I can get on with life.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoI'll never accuse old Windows of being bulletproof, but I've gotten some considerable reliability out of old appliances by adding SSDs, a passively cooled chassis, and a weekly reboot scheduled task. Basically, just get rid of the moving parts and plan for state drift. Old OT is actually pretty easy to take care of aside from sourcing replacements for some secret sauce PCI card that is no longer made. New OT blurs the line with IT in a really difficult way however, you can no longer rely on a dead simple airgap to solve your security concerns because everything and its mother wants to be on the internet.
- fires10 3y agoYou can not just rely on air gapped either. You have other avenues for attack as well. I actually virtualize most of my legacy OSes when possible. Just maintaining adequate serial connections when a USB to serial connector will not work with your legacy OS and a VM can't maintain a stable serial connection through the host OS. It's been a nightmare.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> Running Microsoft Windows. Is Windows 11 with all of the default security settings really that insecure? Like Windows Defender, Windows Firewall, anything that needs admin needed you to click "yes, elevate to admin" through UAC
- hospitalJail 3y agoI just posted this above, but according to Zerodinium, Microsoft Zero Clicks are the highest payout for a desktop OS. Either they are the most secure, or its a popularity thing.
- olyjohn 3y agoAlso maybe because Windows is used heavily in enterprise where there is big money to be stolen from finance departments.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI hate windows, like I'm trying to get off it because of the ads/ragebait news. I hate edge. Microsoft is basically a never buy anymore, but according to this: https://zerodium.com/program.html https://zerodium.com/program.html Getting a Windows exploit is higher value than any linux exploit. Given how many servers use Linux, it makes me wonder if Linux 0 click are easier than windows. There are a bunch of counters like 'there are too many distros', or 'a personal computer of a VIP is higher value than some corporations'. But I'm not sure its fair to include your point number 1. I like to give people credit where its due, I imagine it took lots of work to make windows as secure as it is. (Giving Android OS the most credit for their 2.5M payout)
- Jiocus 3y agoTwo reasons I think Windows exploits would pay higher than 'Linux': 1. The Windows (end-)user base is much larger than Linux (not counting Android), so a Windows exploit enables more potential victims. 2. Windows has been the de-facto corporate OS for a long time, so a Windows exploit offers more high-value targets.
- morpheuskafka 3y agoIt's strange to me that Thunderbird is even on their chart. Surely only a few free software enthusiasts use that anymore? Most of the population doesn't even use a desktop email client and if they do its work-provided Outlook to connect to Exchange/Office365.
- delfinom 3y agohttps://zerodium.com/faq.html https://zerodium.com/faq.html >Zerodium reviews, tests, validates, and documents all acquired vulnerability research then provides it to institutional clients as part of the Zerodium only cares about shit their own customers want to target. They aren't trying to fund the entire world of software security. Their customers in particular are select governments wanting exploits for their own use. You can sure as shit bet they already have specific targets in mind and what they use. EDIT: For example, the forum software noted on Zerodium's list are popular for "blackhat" and "darkweb" forums from everything from card dump selling to malware. Many governments would love to get themselves a database dump with some user IPs. Conversely, this is why Discourse which is a major BB these days is missing as it's not popular in those circles.
- ungruntled 3y agoCompared to Windows, I find that most linux desktop distros have what I would call ‘stability vulnerabilities’ where the user has to tread carefully when doing something basic like updating graphics drivers or applying other updates, or changing resolution. Otherwise they end up with an OS that wont start or will just show a blank screen. I wouldn’t recommend linux for general business or personal use unless this kind of tinkering is enjoyable or you have sufficient IT staff.
- jaredhallen 3y agoI hear this sentiment frequently, but it doesn't match my experience. I sure can relate to the idea, but that was a decade ago. I install a fair variety of Linux distros on a pretty wide variety of hardware between my work and personal efforts, and it pretty much just seems to work these days. The last grief I recall in this regard was trying to run Ubuntu 64 on a Pi4 with Vulkan, but that was a couple years ago when things were known to be unstable. That or maybe doing something obviously inadvisable like trying to change distro on a live system by changing the apt source files on a Debian install to Ubuntu repositories and running an apt upgrade. And honestly even things like that work a surprising amount of the time. I know it's good to be introspective and truthful about shortcomings, but I really have to hand it to all the open source contributors, package maintainers, and all the rest. The modern Gnu/Linux ecosystem is pretty remarkable, in my opinion.
- NewLogic 3y agoOn the contrary, Linus of LTT managed to uninstall the GUI of his PopOS install within an hour while attempting to install Steam only last year. https://youtu.be/0506yDSgU7M?t=618 https://youtu.be/0506yDSgU7M?t=618
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoBy forcibly overriding the safeties that stop you from doing that. I can run `rm -rf --no-preserve-root /` in less than an hour, too, and it's just as meaningful.
- 3y ago
- RobotToaster 3y agoPeople always say this but 1) doesn't even a domestic router block all inbound connections? 2) is there any evidence of unpatched remote vulnerabilities for windows 98?
- userbinator 3y agoYes, and probably not (and even if there were, I suspect no one has a huge incentive to go looking for them anyway.)
- housemusicfan 3y agoI'm glad somebody brought this up. I was waiting for the follow-up article to post on HN about the "Botnet of Windows 98 Machines"
- adamdegas 3y agoYes, all 48 of them.
- jodrellblank 3y ago"Be very careful connecting to some random server and running code from people you've never met, with whom you have no contract or legal comeback, just because other people are doing it. Also, download Debian!"
- anthk 3y agoYou can audit Debian, or rebuild it yourself. Try that with Windows.
- jodrellblank 3y agoDebian had over 324 million lines of code in 2009. How do you propose to audit that in a lifetime? https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/111281/exploding-amount-of-debian-source-code-lines https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/111281/exploding-am...
- anthk 3y agoSo does Guix, and it has reproducibility features and rollbacks.
- userbinator 3y agoThat's pure fearmongering FUD. Recommending Debian to the retrocomputing community is possibly the most tone-deaf thing I've seen today.
- ketralnis 3y agoI'm with you that they could have stopped talking after the word "instead" but the rest is not fearmongering nor FUD: installing operating system patches from a random server on the internet just isn't a great idea
- ckozlowski 3y agoThis. I suppose it can't be helped given the link was posted without context. But yours is the only post here that seems to get it. For everyone else: This project exists for the joy of the retro-computing community. No one in their right mind - retro-computing enthusiasts included - would ever recommend using any of these versions of Windows for anything other than amusement. No, DOSBox is not always an alternative. Retro enthusiasts are quite excited by this project. And for anyone wanting to rebuild an old PC running Win95 for fun, this is going to be a very helpful tool. Michael MJD (YouTube) covered this yesterday in fact: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbeqLmSVqvs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbeqLmSVqvs
- boomboomsubban 3y ago>If you're playing with Microsoft Windows for personal use, that's fine, Saying you're free to have your hobby isn't tone-deaf.
- IntelMiner 3y agoWhen you bury it in FUD it is
- boomboomsubban 3y agoThe "FUD" is clearly describing non-retrocomputing use cases, where everything they said is completely true. If you're use for this project is personal enjoyment, have fun. If it's an important cog in your business, you should probably fix that.