3 ms·
> Standardized testing is the benchmark for efficient signaling. No, it's not. And your anecdote proves it. Or rather, standardized testing just show how wel
by eru 3y ago
> Standardized testing is the benchmark for efficient signaling.
No, it's not. And your anecdote proves it.
Or rather, standardized testing just show how well you do on an exam. That means it tests how smart you are, and how well you can study the material on the test.
But (according to Caplan) that's barely the point in the kind of signalling education is good for. You could mostly just give people an IQ test as part of your hiring process.
Education takes years doing mostly pointless tasks, so that you can signal your long term _conformity_. You might be able to see how an employer might value someone who can credibly show that they can be a good cog in the machine for a long time (even if they don't see the point of the machine).
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> You could mostly just give people an IQ test as part of your hiring process Not allowed. Griggs v. Duke Power Co. "What Congress has forbidden is giving these devices and mechanisms controlling force unless they are demonstrably a reasonable measure of job performance. Congress has not commanded that the less qualified be preferred over the better qualified simply because of minority origins. Far from disparaging job qualifications as such, Congress has made such qualifications the controlling factor, so that race, religion, nationality, and sex become irrelevant. What Congress has commanded is that any tests used must measure the person for the job and not the person in the abstract." So I guess under that decision, they considered IQ tests as measuring the person in the abstract.
- eru 3y agoEh, that decision hasn't hindered companies too much in practice. Eg software companies still give you 'programming problems' that are essentially badly designed IQ tests in disguise. If I remember right, Bryan Caplan addresses this court case in his book already.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> software companies still give you 'programming problems' They've had to come up with all these ridiculous interview techniques when a simple "what's your IQ" would suffice.
- mcphage 3y ago> Education takes years doing mostly pointless tasks, so that you can signal your long term _conformity_. Also persistence—that you started doing something that would take 4 (or more) years, and stuck with it when it got hard.