2 ms·
There is simply no coherent way for any court to apply the law as it exists, given Constitutional supremacy, that doesn’t include judicial review. Whether a pur
by dragonwriter 3y ago
There is simply no coherent way for any court to apply the law as it exists, given Constitutional supremacy, that doesn’t include judicial review. Whether a purported law is law given the Constitutional limits on lawmaking power is, clearly and unmistakably, both itself a controversy arising under the Constitution and laws of the United States and one on which any controversy about the application of the purported law also depends.
Judicial review is not a problem, lack of judicial accountability—arising from structural duopoly, large supermajority requirement for conviction on impeachment, and judicial tenure limited only by impeachment—is the problem.