3 ms·
> The need to have a for profit platform leads to perverse incentives. The need to have profit is the goal of any business. The problem isn't that. The need f
by troupo 3y ago
> The need to have a for profit platform leads to perverse incentives.
The need to have profit is the goal of any business.
The problem isn't that. The need for profit has been entirely replaced with the need for continuous unimpeded growth. Which is decidedly not the same thing, but no one cares anymore, and profit doesn't even come into equation anymore.
- yarg 3y agoWhen the goals of the customers and the goals of the company are at odds, things will never work out long term. But I disagree that the continuous growth model is the cause, although I certainly believe that it frequently adds fuel to the fire (growing a company when it's making a loss on a per customer basis frequently leads to accelerating death spirals as well as all manner of desperate measures).
- troupo 3y ago> But I disagree that the continuous growth model is the cause, When is the last time you've heard a company evaluated on profits (the actual measure of a successful business) and not on growth (of random metrics)?
- criddell 3y agoPublic benefit corporations (like Bluesky) can be run like that.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoI think part of the problem, but also reason for existing, of the growth whatever it takes mindset is, that as long as there is growth, no matter how artificial or not, you can keep up make-belief, that the business is viable and investors are going to belive either just that, or that they can enter now and exit before the bubble bursts. It does not matter to most investors, whether the business is actually viable in the long run, or makes any sense, as long as they see or believe there to be an opportunity to extract money out of the bubble. A bit like trying to extract energy out of vacuum, except, that due to our believe system of economics, it can actually work for them.
- the_other 3y ago> The need to have profit is the goal of any business. This isn't true. A non-profit is still a business. Charities are businesses. Cooperatives can make profit. Also (almost) no-one thinks small businesses making modest profit and riding the ups and downs alongside others in a locale is a problem. The problems arise in companies that choose to only or mainly focus on profit. Most capital funds don't make anything themselves other than money, which they extract from businesses that do make things. You can claim that they're market-correcting forces that allow money to easily move between different areas of human interest... but ultimately their product is their own enrichment. The speed and convenience they provide might be an illusion created by their apparent success. It might be better that our markets and locales develop more slowly; if more smaller scale investors made a wider range of decisions, rather than a handful of large ones making most of them.